Is it possible that legitimate Christian creativity in the area of worship ended a millennium ago?
I don’t think so.
Is it possible that legitimate Christian creativity in the area of worship ended a millennium ago?
I don’t think so.
Finally a moment to sit down. Last weekend my wife & I attended the annual AAR/SBL meeting in San Diego. I’ll make comments on the content of the sessions later. Now I want to make some comments on the travel experience. We spend so much time complaining about things, I thought I’d share our positive experiences.
First, we flew on US Airways. I hadn’t flown on that airline in at least ten years – back when it was known as America West. We flew from DFW to San Diego and back via their hub in Phoenix. Every flight was on time – both at departure and arrival. As far as We can tell, our baggage (checked both directions) was properly routed and handled each time. The only mistake was that on return to Dallas our flight’s luggage appeared on the carousel next to the one advertised. We didn’t buy any of the on board food, but the drink service went fine.
Second, we stayed at the Marriott Hotel & Marina next to the San Diego Convention Center. While it was way out of our normal price range, the hotel room itself was nice an perfectly serviceable. We’d like to have more low price eating options, but plenty were within walking distance. The Starbucks inthe hotel offered breakfast pastries for $3 each, a much better deal than the $18 breakfast buffet. Instead, we walked over to Ralphs and bought a coffee cake and ate on it.
The restaurants we ate at were good also. We ate at Fred’s Mexican Cafe the first night. It was pleasant seating outdoors on the patio, though I managed to sit under one of the heaters. If the restaurant employee hadn’t turned it off (at my request) I would have burned up. We also ate at the Athens Market Taverna. The waiter warned us against each ordering appetizers and entrees – a warning we didn’t need, having eaten at enough restaurants lately to know the normal portion size. We split one appetizer and one entree between us – still way more (tasty) food than we needed. Finally, we also had the lunch buffet at Royal India (another Gaslamp district restaurant). Dangerously tasty. I wish we had one here in our town.
Between the airport and the hotel we rode the Xpress Shuttle. Quick, friendly, efficient service. They also have coupons posted on their site.
Francis of Assisi is frequently quoted approvingly, “Tell of Christ at all times. Use words if necessary.” The implication is that words are rarely needed. If we only act like kind, loving, nice people then others will see Jesus in us and come to faith in him. Acting in a loving way is definitely a sine qua non of evangelism. But it’s just not enough. We humans just aren’t smart enough to get it. A picture just isn’t worth a thousand words in all cases.
Consider the picture Glenn Reynolds posts from Michael Yon. What do you see when you look at the picture? Some guys putting a cross on top of a building. Big deal. But then you hear that it’s from Iraq. Huge deal. But what deal is it? Is it pictorial evidence that the complex event we call “The Iraq War” is just another crusade – that now we’re going so far as to put crosses on top of their buildings? The picture needs words to put it in context. Here are Yon’s contextualizing words (via Instapundit):
“I photographed men and women, both Christians and Muslims, placing a cross atop the St. John’s Church in Baghdad. They had taken the cross from storage and a man washed it before carrying it up to the dome. A Muslim man had invited the American soldiers from ‘Chosen’ Company 2-12 Cavalry to the church, where I videotaped as Muslims and Christians worked and rejoiced at the reopening of St John’s, an occasion all viewed as a sign of hope. The Iraqis asked me to convey a message of thanks to the American people. ‘Thank you, thank you,’ the people were saying. One man said, ‘Thank you for peace.’ Another man, a Muslim, said ‘All the people, all the people in Iraq, Muslim and Christian, is brother.’ The men and women were holding bells, and for the first time in memory freedom rang over the ravaged land between two rivers.”
Very different than the story of Crusades, isn’t it? Instead of a picture that says, “The Christians are here to conquer us and force us to be Christians,” the picture with caption says, “At least this once we’re working across accustomed boundaries – Muslim and Christian, Iraq and American – to do something. We hope this is what happens in the future.”
So please, when you tell people of Jesus, don’t forget to provide a caption for your pictures.
I’ve observed that when a youth ministry is starting – or at a certain kind of transition point – it is common to ask, “What do we do next?” It’s a great question. Unfortunately, one of the common ways to go about it is to ask the youth, “What do you want to do?” In my experience most youth either do not know what they want to do, or else do not have a vision for discipleship with which to align their wants.
Inasmuch as a youth ministry exists within the church, those who do youth ministry are partners with parents. So my suggestion is that we start with the parents. Talk to them.
A root question to ask: “What can we (the church) do to help you raise your kids as Christians?”
This question has some built in assumptions:
Parents have the primary responsibility for raising their kids in Christ. We who are church leaders are their partners and supporters, not their replacements.
The parents want to raise their kids as Christians. This question addresses their standing with Christ.
The parents think about raising their kids as Christians. This question addresses their level of intentionality.
However good our standing is with Christ, however great our intentionality in raising our kids for Christ, we all lack the knowledge and skills to do the job ourselves. This is not a knock on parents. Rather, I believe God plans for Christians – individually and as families – to be interdependent. There will never be a time when we are in line with God’s agenda and able to live and operate self-sufficiently.
After you ask this question, it is possible that parents will have been thinking about the subject and be able to give you a detailed and helpful answer. More likely, however, even dedicated parents will find themselves inexperienced answering such questions. This is partly because we’re trained to think that raising kids – whether in general, or specifically as Christians – is purely an inside job, partly because churches tend not to ask this kind of question of their people. Churches tend to be led by experts. Experts have all the answers. We design and offer programs that impart our answers.
I don’t know about you, but I’ve noticed that most of our answers – our fine honed expertise – doesn’t always work very well. It’s what we know, though, so we keep dispensing it.
So let’s suppose the parents offer some variant of “I don’t know” as an answer. This is a great starting point. They don’t know (and apparently know they don’t know). You don’t know either – and since you’re asking, are perhaps demonstrating to them that you don’t know either. This gives you a perfect opportunity to pray together. You know that God loves their kids (and them) enough to have given Jesus for them. You know that God has broken your heart for the kid(s) through your prayers for him/her. As you pray together – and in my opinion you have to do this out loud (the leader at least – if the parents do also, that’s great, but we don’t compel them) – you pour out your hearts together for the children. Pray expecting God to give you light. It might be that after the prayer you will discover that God has spoken to one of you. If so, share. If not, you might try some guiding questions. Here are some that might help:
“What has God been doing in your life lately?” It could be that what God wants to do in the life of the child will be an outgrowth of what’s happening in the life of the parent. It is very commonly the other way around also..
“What are you doing that builds your own relationship with God?” This assumes the parent is a Christian of some sort.
Following on number 2, “Are there some ways you can draw your child into what you’re doing?”
Even if the parents you speak with are entirely articulate and have specific ideas of what you can do to help them disciple their kids, don’t skip the prayer part. That’s the most important. Also, take what they say seriously. If what they tell you is something you can do, do it. If not (“My kid needs $10,000 so he can do the mission trip to Switzerland”), tell them.
___________________________________________________________
So – what do y’all think of this way of approaching parents?
In an article from Proceedings, Lieutenant Colonel James G. Lacey considers the apparent dependency of US planners on scenarios presented by Samuel Huntington (Clash of Civilizations) and Bernard Lewis (The Crisis of Islam) and finds it wanting. Though he mentions Lewis, his greatest beef is with Huntington. Lacey argues that we tend to confuse Arab Civilization with Muslim Civilization. While most of the former are Muslims, most Muslims are not Arab. Lacey sees Arab civilization as nearing collapse – given it burgeoning youth population and ineffective repressive governments. Muslim civilization, however, appears to be doing just fine.
I haven’t read this particular book by Lewis, so I can’t comment on it. My impression of Huntington is that his thesis that the primary basis of conflict in the near term (at least) will be civilizational rather than ideological seems pretty sound. His greatest weakness has been in understanding the place of religion in civilizations. While the West may be closely associated with Christianity, it is not the case that Christianity now provides the chief public values and agenda for the West, nor that Christianity is only of civilizational significance in the West.
If Lacey is right, what course of action ought we to pursue? He suggests:
The grand strategic concept that provides the best chance of success is the one that served us so well in the Cold War—containment. No matter what else we do we must position ourselves to contain the effects of the complete collapse of Arab civilization. Already 10 percent of the French population is from Muslim North Africa. Europe’s ability to assimilate a larger flood of economic refugees is questionable. And mass migration is just one effect a total collapse will have. Containment will mean adopting and maintaining difficult policy choices, which include:
- Working closely with the European nations to defend their southern border against the mass migration of tens of millions of destitute Arabs as well as armed confrontations with failing Arab states.
- Renewing our close ties with Turkey and making that nation a bulwark against the effects of collapse.
- Working to help modernize and integrate the Russian military into an enhanced European defense structure.
- Ensuring China is a partner in this containment effort.
- Propping up weak border states that are already dealing with the spillover effects of Arab collapse—such as Pakistan and the new Caucasus states.
- Assisting the Iranian popular will to establish a government not based on a religious oligarchy. The Persian people may form an eastern bulwark against collapse.
- Plan for the security of critical resources even during possible upheavals and regional turmoil.
- Spillover effects such as terrorist groups already evident in places like Indonesia and the Philippines must be eradicated or reversed.
- We need to be clear that this is not a failure of Islam. In this regard we must help Muslims outside of the Arab world find their own interpretations of their faith and not fall prey to those being espoused by the Arab world—Wahhabism.
I’d suggest that as Christians – I can’t speak for the US or for the West – that we invest ourselves in presenting Jesus to the nations. In a time of turmoil, we might find more openness than we might otherwise be inclined to expect.
One nation – mentioned by Lacey, but from a govermental not civilizational perspective – to look out for is China. Considering their huge economic growth (and possible upcoming bubble popping), potentially devastating population imbalance (young men outnumbering young women – [sound like the Arab world?]),and the supposed growth of the Christian population, we’ll perhaps see some cracks there also.
Through all this conflict – whether inter or intra civilizational (and, yes, we have our own also) – Christians need to position themselves as friends of the various peoples, not as conquerors or exploiters. Can we act now as those who seek to bless others – whether their civilization is at the top or the bottom, in crisis or perfect stability?
In one of my previous ministry settings our youth group was primarily made up of kids with no previous church connection. They had enthusiasm. They were hungry to know God. They passionately desired their friends to know Jesus. But they had no knowledge or experience when it came to ordinary church life.
We taught them that prayer was an essential part of the Christian life. The prayer life we taught them was not limited to quiet moments alone, but was a struggling with God for people. We started taking them out to pray for others. We’d go door to door through the community. When someone came to the door, one of the kids would say, “We’re the youth group from First Untied Methodist Church. We’re out praying for people. Is there anything we can pray with you about?” As I recollect, not once were the kids turned away. They were received warmly and had many opportunities to pray with people.
We never told the kids that most church folks would never do what they did. Being from a non-church background they just assumed that what we did must be ordinary Christian behavior. What would happen if we long term church folk re-assessed what we take to be ordinary Christian behavior?
We know that ordinary Christians go to church on Sunday. We know that ordinary Christians are fine moral people, upstanding citizens in their communities. We know that ordinary Christians pray, read their bibles and try to be nice to others. But too often we also know that ordinary Christians mind their own business. We know that Christianity – our relationship with God – is too intensely personal to share with outsiders.
In the past I’ve suggested various ways you can be a part of sharing the good news of Jesus. Some of these ways are as simple as inviting (or bringing) someone to church. I’d like to give you another idea this time. Pray for people. I’m not talking just about having a prayer list. That’s a good thing. But what I’m talking about here is doing what those unchurched kids did. Ask someone if there’s something you can pray about with them. If they say yes (and they often will), then do it – then and there, in their presence. Out loud. Why do it out loud? If you do it out loud they will know what you’re doing. You’ll also discover that as you begin praying, especially if you are uncomfortable with the idea, that God will help you. Discomfort on your part – an acknowledged sense of weakness – gives God room to work in your life. That’s what the other folks need to see. It’s ok for them to see that you’re a nice person, that you’re spiritual and that you care for them. Even more important is them seeing God in you.
A few weeks ago the New York Times ran a story on churches using violent video games to attract youth. Now there’s a story out of Alabama about a lock in sponsored by a First United Methodist Church featuring games like Halo. Reflecting on whether this is appropriate or not:
Some churches monitor the games, opting to restrict the games played in church to ones that aren’t violent. Others, however, say children will play the games no matter what, and they might as well play them in church, where adults and ministers can talk to them about their moral implications.
I’ve heard this “they’re going to do it anyway” argument before – usually in relation to sex, drugs & alcohol. There was no indication in the article that the church in question was featuring “safe sex rooms,” or “clean needle rooms,” or “drink till you drop, then sleep it off in safety rooms.” At least not yet.
Talking about the moral and spiritual implications of video games is a good thing. But why do we need to encourage killing (fake) people to do it? Will the kids not know what we’re talking about? I doubt it.
“But the kids won’t come” if we don’t do this! I don’t believe it. Sure, there are some events that some kids won’t come to. (Some kids won’t even come to a “Frag Fest.”) But does the end of getting kids in the door justify any means used? I’ll need to hear some better arguments before I’m convinced.
Here in the Texas Annual Conference of the United Methodist Church we have adopted (in a slightly modified form) the Five Practices of Fruitful Congregations as featured in Bishop Robert Schnase’s book. With some other ideas (“Key Drivers”) added, we’re trying to shape our mission toward more evangelism, discipleship and healthy churches. I’ve preached on several of these over the past couple of years, giving my own take on them. Here they are with links to the mp3 versions:
When I think of preaching, I find the 3 categories of classical rhetoric useful.
1. Ethos – This is our character. People listen to us when they know us to be people of character. Character refers not only to our moral qualities – are we honest and credible, etc. – but also are we interesting? Are we characters? Do we have something to say? As Christian speakers we continually develop our relationships with people – to build trust – and with God, to become interesting people. When we preach we’re putting words to the life of God in us. That’s why traditional teachers of preaching have said that sermon preparation is as much preparing the preacher as preparing the message. To a great extent, the preacher is the message.
2. Logos – Does our message make sense? Is there a logical flow to it? When we prepare a message with logos in mind, we think not only of the logic of the content we’re communicating, but also the logic of our audience. With regard to the first, we approach the text and pursue understanding. We question the text – and let the text question us. The closer we preachers stick to the text (of scripture) the better we do. But we’re not just learning the text for our own sake, but for the sake of our audience. We know our people. The better we know them, the better we can anticipate the questions they would bring to the text – and perhaps the ways the text might question them. The work of anticipating the questions people will have is difficult, but offers the potential of great reward.
3. Pathos – I detest boring sermons. Like it or not, sermons are often the centerpiece of Sunday morning worship in the eyes of many. in worship we seek to meet with the God of the universe. Some in the audience are living on the very edge of commitment. Will they become followers of Jesus? Our words and actions can tip them one way or the other. I never want bore people away from Christ. With pathos we add feeling – energy – to our message. Our character and our logic may be impeccable, but without pathos we leave people disconnected from the truth, unwilling to take up the call of Jesus. In this context we preachers entertain our audience, not in the vulgar sense of merely making them laugh, but in the deep sense of grabbing their attention, waking them as they stumble blindly on the road to death. This is not pathos for the sake of pathos, but pathos – passion – to connect people with the passion of Christ. In preaching pathos and logos are comrades in arms – not competitors.
4. Sometimes a fourth characteristic is added – Mythos. Some preachers are great story tellers. Some use stories to make a point, while some shape the whole sermon as a story. Mythos may include either approach but is to be identified with neither. Rather, mythos looks at the way the sermon fits into the story of God. As Christians, we inhabit a story much larger than ourselves. As preachers, we take cognizance of that story, point our audience toward it, and urge them to become willing participants. Some times our messages will be primarily urging participation in the story. Other times our messages will be primarily giving direction for how to take up our roles in the story – what our next steps might be. Our preaching is not something that takes place outside the story, but is itself an act in the story, so in our preparation we approach it as such. The leading question we ask in prayer as we prepare is, “Lord, given where these people are now, what do they need to hear next as they live as your people?”
At LeadershipJournal.net Steve Gaines writes:
I am convinced that one of the reasons so many people are turned off from the idea of church these days is that it is all so explainable. Too many churches are growing simply because they are well-oiled machines.
For a long time we’ve been taught to think apologetically. We want people to understand us. We want what we do to make sense. I get that idea. But I also see how it is completely misguided.
When we look at the ministry of Jesus we see him doing things that didn’t make sense to his audience. He spent time with the wrong people. He seemed to work harder at provoking confusion than producing understanding. His followers weren’t much better. The first thing the church did was go out in public speaking in tongues. How can you get any weirder and non-sensical than that?
We’ve come such a long way. Joe Non-Believer today understands church all too well. We have meetings. We wear fancy clothes. Depending on Joe’s enculturation he may identify us as either boring or as irrelevant. Either way we can be safely ignored.
Jesus couldn’t be ignored. He provoked a response. The response was either “I will follow you!” or “Crucify him!”
My prayer for my church is that God will do something here that doesn’t make sense – to the world’s way of thinking. I pray that he’ll do something that draw people’s attention to Jesus, something that makes the ask questions.
That’s the original context of the keystone verse of modern apologetics: 1 Peter 3:15. It’s not just “Give a reason for the hope you have.” It’s more “When people see you suffering they’ll see that you are submitting to it voluntarily out of devotion to Christ. Your life as followers of Jesus – as people who have taken up your crosses and follow him – simply won’t make sense to them. They’ll feel compelled to ask questions. When they ask you to explain your insanity, tell them about Jesus.”
Steve Gaines has it right. We can be weird all day along. It’s not weird qua weird that makes a difference. It’s God in us that makes a difference, that attracts people and draws them to Jesus. I’m tired of settling for just a well-oiled machine.