Slippery Jesus

We who delve into the bible and lead congregations… Yes, it appears possible to do the one and not the other: One can delve into the bible purely for personal benefit, or one can lead congregations and ignore the bible. But the best option is to delve into the bible, thereby listening to God, and from that listening, lead God’s people. Surely this leadership need not be from the top – from the position of pastoral CEO or Chair. Bible-produced leadership is just as possible from someone who has no official position.

Back to the original thought. Here I am, delving into my bible and leading congregations (I speak of my life over the past 20 years). I find myself in an uncomfortable place. One of the things I find in the bible is that people need Jesus. This bible-enunciated need has also been evidenced by what I see in actual living, breathing people. I need Jesus. Other folks need Jesus.

Have you ever noticed, however, that many people either don’t think they need Jesus or if they see the need, fail to act on it? I’ve been lost, so I know what it is to be blind to the Gospel. I’m a sinner, so I know what it is to not act on what I know I need to do. The confusion I’m talking about today is with the church (sinners within) rather than sinners without.

Almost every church I’ve pastored would have defended the idea that it is the church’s job to join in God’s work of helping people know Jesus. Almost as universally, these churches have acted like meeting the needs of church members and keeping them happy  is the most important task of the church (or of the pastor, as the case may be). Those folks out there ought to come to our programs and participate in our ministries.

But they don’t. At least not enough to staunch a decades long decline in United Methodism as a whole – and most of our congregations taken individually.

Faced with these details, many who speak up for leadership in the church tell us we need to change. We need to get back to God. Out of obedience to God we need to do everything possible to fulfill the Great Commission – and to lead our churches in that direction. Yes! my heart says. That’s exactly what we need to do. If some of the members aren’t up to it, if they want to stick with the old ways that continue to not win the lost, well, they can just be lost themselves. The changes we need to make to fulfill the Great Commission will necessarily leave some behind, since not all are concerned with the Great Commission, apparently preferring to keep things they way they’ve always been. Nice and comfortable.

New pastors come to these “don’t rock the boat” churches with instructions to “reach people,” to “grow the church.” The old timers don’t know what hit them. They just know that their church has been taken from them. Or… the hard charging, determined-to-reach-the-lost-at-any-cost  pastor is run off with this tail between his legs, either to go plant a church, try another transformation, or to sell insurance.

Where does Jesus fit in this mix (mess)? We could look at John 10 – the Good Shepherd. He’s a good enough shepherd that he doesn’t lose any. That’s way better than any shepherd (pastor) I’ve ever known. We all lose some, if for no other reason that we’re different from the last pastor. Surely the pastor who read John 10 and patterned ministry after Jesus would do everything to make sure none were lost?

Maybe. Maybe not. What about the Jesus of John 6? That Jesus begins well – feeding the multitude. We all like a free lunch. But by the end of the chapter he’s gotten so controversial that most of the crowd has left in disgust. He turns to the twelve. “Hey! Do you guys want to leave also? If so, you better hit the road.” Where’s the Good Shepherd who wants to keep everyone, no matter the cost?

Jesus is slippery. He just doesn’t fit our models.

Some of us like the model of Jesus as chaplain. Be nice. Make everyone happy. Don’t rock the boat.

Some of us like the model of Jesus the creator of storms. Stir things up. Cause a ruckus. Polarize.

Well, which is it? Do we pastors work our tails off to make everyone happy so no one ever leaves? Or do we push radical change to reach the lost, regardless of who (or how many) may depart in the interim?  I – with the help of Jesus – could make either case.

But I don’t think either is the right place to begin.

Instead, let’s consider stepping back and engaging Jesus in his context. Instead of taking our perception of our own context and laying Jesus (or our abstractions of Jesus) on top of them, let’s do what Jesus did. Put ourselves entirely at God’s disposal. Regular prayer and fasting. A broken heart for people – those on the inside, those on the outside. An irrationally stubborn commitment to his mission (how rational do you think it is to forego a quiet life of carpentery – or fishing – to go to Jerusalem to be betrayed, whipped and crucified?) regardless of how people responded (his best buds all ran away. Oh. All but two. One betrayed him, the other stayed close enough to deny him).

What would happen if we congregational leaders followed this Jesus – regardless of whether it made people happy or not? Regardless of whether it brought in the crowds or not?

It may be that we’ll be crucified. Wouldn’t be the first time. But it just may well be that we’ll hear, “Well done, good and faithful servant.”

Posted in Bible, church growth, Jesus, Leadership, Ministry, United Methodism | 5 Comments

Muslim Outreach

A group of Muslims from around the world have issued an open letter to Christian leaders everywhere. The call for peace is summed up in the beginning of the document:

Muslims and Christians together make up well over half of the world’s population. Without peace and justice between these two religious communities, there can be no meaningful peace in the world. The future of the world depends on peace between Muslims and Christians.
The basis for this peace and understanding already exists. It is part of the very foundational principles of both faiths: love of the One God, and love of the neighbour. These principles are found over and over again in the sacred texts of Islam and Christianity. The Unity of God, the necessity of love for Him, and the necessity of love of the neighbour is thus the common ground between Islam and Christianity.

The rest of the document lays out the two commandments – Love God and Love Neighbor – as the common ground between Christians and Muslims, showing both Quranic and Biblical support for the commands. What ought we to make of it?

Christianity Today is tracking some responses – so far mostly positive. John F Cullinan, an adjunct fellow at the Hudson Institute’s Center for Religious Freedom, is less optimistic, calling attention to violence within Islamic practice and in the advice in the Quran itself. Do these “functionaries” actually speak for Islam?

My answer would be that surely they do speak for Islam, unless by “speak for Islam” you mean something like the Pope speaking for the Roman Catholic Church. These Islamic scholars, leaders, and “functionaries” do not have the same kind and extent of authority in Islam that the Pope has in Catholicism. But that doesn’t matter.

In Whose Justice? Which Rationality? Alasdair MacIntyre defines a tradition:

 “A tradition is an argument extended through time in which certain fundamental agreements are defined and redefined in terms of two kinds of conflict: those with critics and enemies external to the tradition who reject all or at least key parts of those fundamental agreements, and those internal, interpretive debates through which the meaning and rationale of the fundamental agreements come to be expressed and by whose progress a tradition is constituted.”

This is a philosophical definition. It is not an exact match with Christian, Catholic, Protestant, Muslim or any other group’s understanding of tradition – but I would identify it as a possible general account of each of these more particular offerings.
What we see in the Common Ground letter is an instance of both external and internal conflict – or to use a more appropriate and irenic word – conversation. While explicitly addressed to Christians as a statement of Islamic thought and practice, it also functions as a move within Islam, a move very different from what we see the Taliban, Al Qaeda and the like making. Do they speak for Islam as a whole or for a majority of Muslims? While the answer to that question may have political import, I think it’s mostly irrelevant. As a Christian – and as a citizen of a country and participant in a culture that at least some Muslims have dedicated themselves to eradicate – I’m quite happy to hear that the there are other ways to be Muslim.

But that’s just it. There isn’t just one way to be a Muslim, just as there isn’t just one way to be a Christian. Both our traditions are in flux, in a continual effort of definition and redefinition. Each of us who speak for our traditions – I use “speak for” in a smaller sense than one would predicate of a Pope or Ayatollah – are participating in this work of definition and redefinition. Whether these guys “speak for Islam,” are representative of the majority of Muslims, or even get Islam “right” is irrelevant. From my point of view as a Christian, we are better off if they are right, if their position does prevail in Islam. I think they’d be better off for it also.

So what do we do if we feel positive about their statement? That could be tricky.  If you’re a Christian leader like I am, you could start by saying there is a movement within Islam that seeks to define it as what we on the outside would perceive as a religion of peace, and that they want to live in peace with those of us who are not Muslims. We can go further and tell them that from what we see, their’s is not the only interpretation of Islam currently available (they already know that from the news, so you’re just telling them your head isn’t in the sand), but is well worth encouraging.

The tricky part might come in how are positive response is taken by their foes within Islam. OBL and his ilk might reason, “These folks are reaching out to infidels. The infidels like what they say.  That means these so called Muslims are really infidels also.”  Personally I don’t care what OBL et al. say. And apparently the folks who wrote this document don’t either. They boldly set forth a “peace is possible with Christianity” version of Islam as true Islam, regardless of what their internal competitors might say.

“But do they really mean it?” We have to decide that about every momentous conversation we have. My perspective is, “Sure they mean it.” And they’ll mean it even more if they get a positive response from it.

“Do we agree with it all?” It’s too big a document to speak meaningfully of agreement on every level. A centerpiece of their argument is a quote from the Quran:

Say: O People of the Scripture! Come to a common word between us and
you: that we shall worship none but God, and that we shall ascribe no
partner unto Him, and that none of us shall take others for lords beside
God. And if they turn away, then say: Bear witness that we are they who
have surrendered (unto Him). (Aal ‘Imran 3:64)

The phrase “ascribe no partner unto Him” has a history of use by Muslims to argue against the doctrine of the Trinity. If we endorse (the language of their website) or receive (language I’d prefer) this document, are we admitting the history of this phrase from a Muslim perspective, i.e., repudiating our Trinitarian faith? I don’t think so. Though the phrase is repeated many times in the text, not once is it raised as a club to bludgeon – or argue with – the Christians. They assume that Christians are monotheists – inspite of our Trinitarianism. That’s where I stand also – I’m a Trinitarian and a monotheist. So I can read this document as them getting us right.

In the end, I take this document as a positive step. I am willing to recognize that Muslims and Christians hear a common call to love God and love neighbor – and that we can include each other within the definition of neighbor, and thus look at each other as people to love.

Posted in Al Qaeda, Alasdair MacIntyre, Clash of Civilizations, Current events, Islam, Theology, Tradition, War | Leave a comment

Does Pacifism Work?

Some of noted Gandhi-style pacifist protest works better with some groups than others. If you are protesting against a group that thinks its wrong to kill unarmed protesters you’re more likely to survive than if, as in Myanmar, you go up against people who just kill any opposition that gets in the way.

Some might consider this an effective argument against pacifism. If pacifism is put forth because it works better than violence or force, then yes, such an argument would have force. But at least some of the pacifists I know consider pacifism to be right regardless of whether it works or not.

Posted in Current events | 7 Comments

Why Bother?

Have you ever been involved in something – maybe something you count as of great importance – only to have your involvement ignored or rejected? If you’re the type of person who is concerned enough about others to move beyond meeting your own needs and fulfilling your own desires, than chances are you’ve experienced such rejection in one form or another.

We know Jesus came to bring salvation to Israel and to the world. We know his love for his people was intense. We also know that “his own did not receive him.” That’s an understatement, isn’t it? They not only didn’t receive him, they killed him. You can’t get much more rejected than that.

What do you do when you feel rejected? Well, what did Jesus do?

When things don’t go our way we commonly think there are two options. First, we go on the offensive. If they are going to reject us, then we’ll just reject them! We’ll give them what they deserve. This is a variety of the kind of reasoning we see in “an eye for an eye.”

A second common response is withdrawal. If they don’t want me, if they don’t want my contribution, then I’ll just quit. I’ll just go home. Makes sense, doesn’t it? If we hear people saying, “We don’t want you,” we find it natural to oblige them.

Which of these two strategies did Jesus use? When he was arrested, did he put up a stout defense – either verbally or physically? When they started to scourge him or later crucify him, did he respond in kind? Not at all. How about withdrawal? When people rejected his teaching, argued with him, and accused him of doing the work of the devil, did he withdraw? Did he just give up on them and go away. No, he didn’t do that either. So what did he do?

Jesus’ starting point was that he knew who he was. His identity was not based on what he did – or how people responded to what he did – but on who he was. He lived continually in a love relationship with the Father. He knew that no matter what happened, the Father loved him and he loved the Father.

At the same time, Jesus did what he did not primarily to produce a response form the people to whom he was sent, but out of love to the Father. Whether his audience responded favorably or not, his calling was to love the Father. This eternal love relationship with the Father formed the context of Jesus’ actions. This relationship relativized everything else. “The people reject me? Yep. But the Father accepts me!”

Because of Jesus’ security in the Father, he was able to “sit back and take it” when his own people rejected him. It was this security that enabled him to say – from his heart – “Father, forgive them, they know not what they do.” After his death and resurrection, some of the very people who were actively involved in crucifying Jesus came to faith in him. God worked through their rejection to bring about something greater – something unimaginable beforehand.

Jesus calls us to take up our crosses and follow him. His invitation is the voice of love. He loves us, so he invites us to be involved in what he is doing. We can have security in his acceptance of us regardless of what anyone else may say or do. And if the New Testament is correct, we will face rejection, discomfort, frustration and pain. As followers of Jesus, he gifts us with the Holy Spirit to enable us to respond to all this the same way he himself responded to rejection, desertion, arrest and crucifixion.

So why bother? Because we are followers of Jesus, what is important to him is important to us. What breaks his heart, breaks our hearts. It’s that dangerous thing called love. Though painful, love is always the right thing to do.

Posted in Spirituality | Leave a comment

Dealing with Doubt

How do you handle doubt? We who are prone to doubting can doubt just about anything. We can doubt God – his existence, his goodness, his concern for us. We can doubt ourselves – our value, our purpose in life, our relationships. Some of our doubts are about facts – details of reality. Other doubts are about our interpretations of events and the people around us. Still other doubts are about the proper course of action in a situation.

 For some of us, doubting is a part of our personality. It’s our native language. Others of us doubt because Western culture has taught us to over the past 300 years or so.

 When I think about the things I know for sure, many are trivial. I don’t think to doubt them because they are constants in my experience. Of all the times I’ve driven to work since I’ve lived here, I have never found the church buildings to have wandered off.

 Some of the things I know for sure are immensely important. I know my family loves me. Knowing also that I’m not always lovable, I’ve been given reasons over and over again why I shouldn’t doubt their love.

 When it comes to the Christian faith, Jesus is my anchor. From my first semester in college I have been confronted with scholarship that sought to marginalize Jesus or to put him in an inadequate category: Good Teacher, Moralist, Cynic, Revolutionary. After years of study I still find the traditional picture of Jesus – God incarnate, demonstrating God’s ways in his life and teaching, bearing our sins on the cross, rising again on the third day – to not merely be the most satisfying, but the most intellectually satisfying picture. Can I answer all the questions? Not at all. But I’m not afraid of the questions and can answer them to my own satisfaction.

 Part of my job flows directly from my interaction – intellectual and personal – with Jesus. I’m more comfortable with those parts. Other parts, however, take me far away from my anchor – into uncharted (or, more accurately, confusingly charted) waters. Leadership, in particular, comes to mind. I know leadership doesn’t come naturally to me. I’ve read tons of books on the subject. I’ve found theories and practices that make good sense. But they don’t feel right or conflict with equally sensible theories. So I’m left not knowing what to do.

 How’s your doubt life? Have you discovered yet that shutting them out or ignoring them doesn’t work? Have been overwhelmed by them? I’ll leave you with just one word of advice. Share your doubts with God – even if you doubt God. See what happens.

Posted in Spirituality, Theology | 1 Comment

Beware Doctors in Church

There is a common assumption that those who have earned a doctoral degree are smarter than those who haven’t. This assumption is most unfortunate when it is held by those of us who have earned doctorates.

As they exist today, the doctoral degrees with which I am familiar are based on narrow specialization. That’s why people describe the process as “learning more and more about less and less until you know everything about nothing.” That narrow specialization provides us with the tools to train others to be narrowly specialized – thus giving us employment to the extent that there are people who currently value our narrow field of specialization.

No one has a doctorate in life – life’s just too big. Those who do best in life are not even those who know the most. Rather, those who are wise do best. Having a great deal of specialized knowledge does not necessarily impede wisdom, but to the degree that we think our (small) world of specialized knowledge is the best way to approach the (large) world of life as a whole, we will inevitably lapse into foolishness.

“To the man with a hammer, everything looks like a nail.” A doctorate is a mighty fine hammer. We’ve invested years of toil and self-denial as well as piles of money to earn them. After we finally have our hammer, we sure want to use it. “Hey! Look at all those nails!”

Only this week have I begun to understand why some have spoken of a bias against pastors with PhDs. We PhD types have been so narrowly trained into our small area of knowledge, with its exacting standards, that we try to bring those standards with us back to our churches when we pastor. Unfortunately, the standards of graduate school and academia, fine as they are in that setting, are not the standards of the church. Those of us who take our heads out of our books for a few minutes will admit to that. But then we’re faced with a choice. Do we judge the church standards defective because they don’t measure up to our own? Do we judge the standards of our discipline defective because they don’t measure up to the church? Or can we take a third option: The standards of the church and the standards of our discipline – even our disciplines that might find a natural home in the church – are simply different.

What happens if we take this third option? We recognize that the neither the standards of the church nor the standards of our discipline are simply universal. Each inhabits a particular social setting. Once we do this we can give a little. The mission of the church is to make disciples. While my discipline (theology) can be an aid to this mission, it is not the same thing as that mission. When I insist that everything we do that has flavored by theology (all teaching, for example) be up to the standards of my academic discipline, I find myself – and put the rest of the church – in an impossible bind. In trying to impose the standards inherent to my discipline, I displace the standards of the church.

I like the discipline of theology. I find working in it very rewarding. But my calling is to submit my practice of that discipline to the mission of the church. Consequently, I sometimes have to shelve my standards and settle for (what I as a theologian might call) “good enough.”

A brief example. We’re doing a confirmation class in our church now. As a theologian I can think of enough things that the kids need to learn that would keep them in class for years. But that won’t work. It’s utterly unrealistic. Instead, I need to settle for good enough. It chafes my professional attitude to have to settle for what I think of as minimal knowledge (they still think it’s a lot). However much pain it causes me, I think I’m right to compromise my standards here, in light of my audience, the local context, and the mission of the church. If the mission of the church were to produce dozens of well qualified theologians, it’d be different (and in our setting, we’d likely fail miserably).

So can we handle PhDs in church leadership positions? Sure – if we learn to submit ourselves to the mission of the church. and learn to take ourselves a little less seriously.

Posted in church growth, Education, Higher Education, Leadership, Local church | Leave a comment

Littering Immigrants

I received one of those “cute” stories via forwarded email today. This time it was about a home owners association that was fed up with the food wrappers that blew into their neighborhood from “Mexicans” working at a nearby construction site. Frustrated, they came up with a plan. They formed a group called “Inner Neighborhood Services,” made themselves blue windbreakers and caps with the group’s initials (INS), armed themselves with cameras and clipboards, and went to “police” the trash. As the story goes, the workers saw them and most never came to work again.

The “moral” of the story is that the government is incompetent or unwilling to do anything about immigration (the story isn’t really about litter), so ordinary citizens need to apply their own ingenuity to get rid of them.

Snopes.com identifies this story as an Urban legend – not an actual occurrence. But how might it have worked if something like this happened in a Christian neighborhood?

Perhaps the Christians would have noticed that most of the workers were immigrants. Knowing that immigrants are sometimes easy to intimidate and take advantage of, their hearts would have gone out to them. “Those guys work hard all day. Their employers don’t even provide them a place to throw away their lunch wrappers. How about we pool our resources and start preparing a tasty and healthy lunch for them? That we can not only meet their need for food, but also help them make friends in the community. Who knows, maybe we’ll even learn something from them?”

Posted in Immigration | 1 Comment

Continuing through 1 John

Since I’ll be out of my Sunday school class again this week (teaching the youth class), I’ve again prepared a lesson for them. Here it is in case anyone else might profit from it.

Sunday School Questions – 1 John 2 part 3

NRS 1 John 2:7 Beloved, I am writing you no new commandment, but an old commandment that you have had from the beginning; the old commandment is the word that you have heard. 8 Yet I am writing you a new commandment that is true in him and in you, because the darkness is passing away and the true light is already shining.

Don’t you love John’s style? “I’m not writing you a new commandment, only an old one. But, yes, I’m writing a new one also.” What do you think is going on here? What have you seen in the text of 1 John so far that you think John’s audience would take as “nothing new?” Do you see anything yet that was likely new to them? (One possibility is that “new” has the sense here of “renewed.” Sure, it’s an old commandment, but it finds new statement – or restatement in new terms – in the life and teaching of Jesus.)

John says the new commandment is “true in him and in you.” What does it mean to say that a commandment is “true?” It seems more common to say that a commandment is “authoritative,” “wise,” “good for us.” But “true?” But then it’s not simply “true,” but “true in him and in you.” Who is the “him” John is thinking of? How is a command true in a person? Looking at yourselves, what might it mean to say that a commandment is true in you? One possibility is that John is saying that the commandment has been truly expressed in the life of Jesus – not just words from his mouth, but enacted in his life – and that in a similar way the commandment is now being enacted by the people in his audience. (The NIV translation – “Its truth is seen in him…” supports this idea.) If you think this is a possible interpretation, how do you see commandments enacted in your own lives?

Now we come to another question of interpretation. Does the explanatory phrase at the end of v. 8 explain “I am writing” or “is true?” In other words, is John writing what he is because of this change in circumstances, that is, that the darkness is passing away and the true light is already shining – or is the commandment “true in him and in you” because of those circumstances? Both the NIV and the NRS are ambiguous. The New Living Translation, however, drops the “I am writing” phrase leaving the explanation to apply simply to the truth of the commandment.

What might it mean that the “darkness is passing?” Would you prefer that it be “the darkness is past – since darkness has a negative connotation here? What is meant by “the true light?” How does what John says here relate to what you find in John 1:9-12; 3:16-21; 8:12; Romans 13:11-14; Ephesians 5:8; Colossians 1:0-14; 1 John 1:5-7?

NRS 1 John 2:9 Whoever says, “I am in the light,” while hating a brother or sister, is still in the darkness. 10 Whoever loves a brother or sister lives in the light, and in such a person there is no cause for stumbling. 11 But whoever hates another believer is in the darkness, walks in the darkness, and does not know the way to go, because the darkness has brought on blindness.

John continues his use of light language. What actions does he describe as clearly incompatible with walking in the light – embodying the truth of the commandment? Do you agree with him about this? Why or why not? If he’s right, why is hating apparently so common among those who call themselves believers?What might cause one believer to hate another? What effect does this hatred have on the hater? The hated? On the church as a whole? The word translated “stumbling” is the word skandalon. I bet you can figure out what English word we get from that. If we think of hate among believers as a “scandal,” what does it add to our understanding of this passage?

Posted in Bible, Spirituality | Leave a comment

Lion Chaser Manifesto

I first heard of Mark Batterson from the Granger guys (Tim Stevens & Tony Morgan), and visited his church last year when I was in town for the AAR. It looks like a great thing is happening there – though I couldn’t imagine smiling as much as Mark does.

Mark recently shared what he calls the “Lion Chaser Manifesto” while at Granger (read his book if you want a more developed picture):

Quit living as if the purpose of life is to arrive safely at death. Set God-sized goals. Pursue God-ordained passions. Go after a dream that is destined to fail without divine intervention. Keep asking questions. Keep making mistakes. Keep seeking God. Stop pointing out problems and become part of the solution. Stop repeating the past and start creating the future. Stop playing it safe and start taking risks. Expand your horizons. Accumulate experiences. Consider the lilies. Enjoy the journey. Find every excuse you can to celebrate everything you can. Live like today is the first day and last day of your life. Don’t let what’s wrong with you keep you from worshipping what’s right with God. Burn sinful bridges. Blaze a new trail. Criticize by creating. Worry less about what people think and more about what God thinks. Don’t try to be who you’re not. Be yourself. Laugh at yourself. Quit holding out. Quit holding back. Quit running away. Chase the lion!

I’m not sure what to do with this.

On the one hand, it’s a fine distillation of the kind of inspirational challenge one gets from reading certain missionary biographies. I like the excitement it suggests. I heartily believe – and preach – that the Christian life is an adventure. Too many Christians are missing out on this dimension of the faith.

On the other hand, it also sounds like a manifesto for modern American individualism with some Christianese added in.

As a recovering individualist, my first response was, “Yeah! I wish all my people would read this and do it!” But what do we do with the people – who are often dependent on us in some way or another – who cannot or will not “chase the lion?” I have three kids. They need parents who are faithful and dependable – predictable even. “Hey kids! I see a lion over there I need to chase. Y’all fix your own dinner tonight. What? I never got around to filling the pantry? I’m sure you’ll think of something. Bye.” I don’t know if that will work well except for Mr & Mrs Tarzan.

In my situation in particular my oldest child has special needs. With her autism she can’t handle the intensity of the Lion Chasing life (there have been many times I’d like to chase lions but my responsibility for her has held me back).

Or what do I do as a pastor? Do I tell people, “Either adopt a lion chasing life style or find another church – there’s a nice sedate hospice church right around the corner.” While I think some of our elderly folks may have missed out on a lot by living calm (boring, by my standards) Christian lives, I’m not comfortable running so fast I leave them in the dust.

Now if we can read the Manifesto not as something I do, but as something WE do, I think it might work better for our churches – and be a better way to not run beyond the least of these our brethren. Read as a community manifesto it can spur the community as a whole to find the adventure of the Christian life.

Posted in church growth, Granger Community Church, Leadership, Mark Batterson, Ministry, Salvation, Spirituality | Leave a comment

Islam & Tradition

In my position as a pastoral leader of a church, I have been frequently asked lately, “What is a Muslim? What do they believe? Are terrorism and violence part of their religion?” Although my expertise is not in world religions, I do know from my reading that the “Five Pillars” of Islam are most central. The concept of jihad, which has featured so prominently in world events of late, seems central to Islam also. The Muslim voices we hear are not unanimous. Some claim that Jihad is an internal struggle against the forces of sin and evil. Others characterize it as in external struggle against the enemies of Allah. Which voice is the authentic voice of Islam? The best answer, I believe, is “We’ll see.”

 Alasdair MacIntyre defines a tradition as an “argument extended through time in which the fundamental agreements are defined and redefined in terms of two kinds of conflict: those with critics and enemies external to the tradition who reject all or at least key parts of those fundamental agreements, and those internal, interpretive debates through which the meaning and rationale of the fundamental agreements come to be expressed and by whose progress a tradition is constituted.” My assumption in this essay is that whatever else we say about Islam (or Christianity for that matter), it can be seen as a tradition in MacIntyre’s sense. Thus answering the question, “What is Islam?” entails identifying both the central agreements within the tradition as well as the conflicts that are in progress both internally and externally. Seeing Islam in this way raises a number of questions for our current situation.

First, from our perspective outside the Islamic tradition, we see what looks like an internal argument about the nature of jihad, and argument that is variously related to other internal arguments, especially those regarding the relation of Islam to democracy, free market capitalism, secularity and modernity. Some affirm that each of these is compatible with Islam, while others claim they are of Satan. Though as outsiders we are not part of the argument, my guess is we would prefer those who argue for jihad as internal spiritual struggle to some out on top. Our daily news features those who argue for external jihad; we also hear local Muslim leaders publicly identify jihad as internal. My question is: where is this debate taking place within Islam? How important is resolution of the question for those within the tradition? How are the arguments taken beyond the theoretical to the practical, i.e., to the protesters in Pakistan and Gaza City? What are the consequences of the perversion of jihad in the eyes of both sides? Whom can we outsiders observe to see the pursuit of the “jihad as internal struggle” position within the Muslim world, i.e., those who frame the issue for internal audiences?

Second, what role ought we on the outside to take in this struggle? On the one hand, we have no more business telling Muslims what to believe (and practice!) regarding jihad than they do in helping us refine the doctrine of the Trinity. On the other hand, however, the position that becomes constitutive of “true” Islam has a direct bearing on we who are outside the tradition. If  “jihad as external” becomes central to Islam in a way analogous to the role now played by their confession or by fasting during Ramadan, then the stance of those outside Islam will already be determined – friendship and cooperation will become impossible. Since we don’t want this to happen, what course of action ought we to take?

Perhaps political partnerships with Muslims ought to be pursued. But with which Muslims? From a political point of view, do we partner in Egypt with President Mubarak’s government or with Islamic Jihad? In Pakistan do we partner with the government of president Musharraf or with the crowds of protesters (and where do we stand with the country as a whole that applies Sharia law in a way that leads to the persecution of Christians)? In Palestine do we partner with Arafat or Hamas? We don’t have to go very far in the Muslim world to discover that they have demagogues and poor leadership just as other countries do.

Perhaps we ought instead to simply side with those who proclaim Jihad as internal struggle, regardless of their nationality or political affiliation. But how would such a partnering be seen by Muslims on the other side of the argument? Would it make our apparent allies guilty of heresy through association? I can easily imagine someone, perhaps Mullah Omar of the Taliban arguing with an adherent of the “jihad as internal struggle” position something like this: “You say that jihad is merely an internal spiritual struggle. The Americans say that your interpretation is correct. If the Americans take that position it must be wrong. Therefore your position is discredited.” My original question – what ought we to do in light of this internal argument within Islam – is no closer to an answer.

Third, what resources for the pursuit of peace with outsiders can one find within Islam and its history? Obviously this question can be asked of any major tradition with socio-political significance in today’s world. Christians first observed jihad in the 7th century when the Muslims conquered Christian North Africa. They continued to experience holy war in the next century as Muslims moved into the heart of Europe. The church in the west decided to try holy war on its own during the crusades. Sometime in the centuries since the crusades, however, the mainstream of the Christian tradition has come to see holy war as repugnant to the core of that tradition. This is not to say that nations identified in some way as Christian nations no longer pursue war – they do so for a myriad of reasons. Religion simply tends not to be one of the rationales offered. (I would say that killing in the name of progress, capitalism or the nation state is not an improvement over killing in the name of God.)

That a “Christian” nation can go to war with no consideration of their actions in terms of Christian teaching is likely to make little sense to traditions, like Islam, that either see no distinction between church and state, or see such a distinction as horribly misguided. Is it possible for there to be a peace tradition within Islam that can critique the actions of Islamic governments in the name of Islam? There are plenty of recent examples of traditions within Islam of critiquing Islamic governments in the name of Islam – the Muslim Brotherhood built on the idea of Sayid Qutb is a prime example – but the difference in this case is looking for a focus on peace with outsiders. One candidate for such a tradition is the movement of ijtihad – a focus on independent, critical thinking – espoused by Irshad Manji. Whether this becomes a tradition within Islam depends on whether Manji can build a following that will outlast her own life. Perhaps a better example is the work of Fethullah Gulen in Turkey. His development of ijtihad seems to go farther than Manji’s. As he employs the concept, it functions as an explicit realization that Islam can be characterized as a MacIntyrean tradition. Ijtihad is then the process of engaging with differences within and without to discern the proper way to be Muslim. How does this tie in with a quest for peace? Traditional Islam divides the world into dar-al-Islam and dar-al-harb – the House of Islam and the House of War. The differentiating factor is whether Muslims rule or not. Where Muslims rule, one finds dar-al-Islam. Where non-Muslims rule, one finds dar-al-harb. Gulen has proposed that in place of dar-al-harb, we ought to think of dar-al-hizmet – the House of Service. When Muslims are not in control, it is their job to demonstrate loving service.

But these are arguments internal to Islam. I suspect most of my readers are neither Muslims nor inhabitants of a Muslim country. What are we outsiders to make of jihad  as it now exists? What are the social implications for us? The position that jihad refers to external conflict clearly has public and political consequences. Once such a position is taken, certain courses of action seem clear. But what if one takes the other position? What public and political actions would an internal view of jihad entail? As moderns who assume the privatization of religion we have no trouble understanding such in internalization. But what are the communal consequences of this internalization?

Fourth, what does the ideal outcome of each position look like? If the Taliban and their ideological partners within Islam prevail in every way, what would the world look like? Perhaps we could ask this another way. If Allah were to be satisfied with life on earth, what would it look like? Would the description of such a world center on internal dispositions and the actions of individuals? Or would it center on a picture of society and culture? To some of us on the outside it looks like the Taliban and their allies would like the world to look like 7th century Arabian culture. Dare we ask if a world with our current population patterns would work if ordered along the lines of such a culture?

This fourth question has become that of the relation between religion and culture. In the west we tend to speak – simplistically, I believe – in terms of church and state. The broader categories of religion and culture are much more helpful. Through the outworking of the doctrine of the Incarnation the Christian tradition has become wildly multicultural. There are Christians in almost all cultures in the world – and they all look different, significantly shaped as they are by their host cultures. To what degree can Islam be multicultural? Certainly insofar as Islam has a doctrine of Creation akin to Christianity, a universality similar to that found in Christianity can be found. But at the heart of Christianity is the Creator become human while at the heart of Islam is the revelation of the Quran. From this initial “translation” event onward, translation has been a normal and expected part of the tradition. I am told than in Islam, however, the Quran is most truly the Quran in Arabic, its original language.

This raises a further related question. One way to understand what is going on in fundamentalism is to see such movements as a denial of MacIntyre’s claim that traditions are constituted by arguments extended through time. In other words, they view the tradition at its origin at its purest in its founding. Any deviation from what it was in the beginning is at best a degradation, at worst the foulest heresy. (I heard that sentiment expressed today by someone who said that Islam simply is about killing non-Muslims. He, a non-proponent of Islam, took the actions of Muslims from the news as expressive of the true essence of Islam.) The only way to progress, given such a conviction, is by going backwards. What is the place of such a position in Islam? I know through experience that such a position – the denial that Christianity is a tradition changing through time, not merely an eternal essence –  exists within the American Christian tradition, yet I also know that there are rich and varied resources for understanding and guiding the development of the tradition in a changing world. What is the role of fundamentalism (as I’ve defined it) in Islam? Is there room for a conviction that a community can be faithful to Islam and develop some form of a modern economy, democratic institutions, and live at peace with non-Muslim countries? Can Islam today look different from the Islam of Mohammed (or of the Caliphate) and still be faithful? Leaders like Irshad Manji and Fethullah Gulen think so. Only time will tell.

Posted in Alasdair MacIntyre, Clash of Civilizations, Current events, Globalization, Islam, War | Leave a comment