Jesus vs the gods

I just finished a sermon series on Jesus vs the gods. The “gods” I referred to in the messages were names from the ancient world: Greco-Roman names plus one, Mammon, from the Semitic world. Those their names aren’t as much in use today (though given some of the recent re-paganization, we’ll see what happens), the ideas and values they embodied are still quite popular.

Posted in Christianity, Consumerism, Culture, God, Jesus, Preaching | Tagged , , , , | Leave a comment

The Chosen, Season 5 Episode 2

Season 5 depicts the beginning of Passion Week. It’s framed by teaching of Jesus from the Upper Room Discourse in the Gospel of John with bits from Luke 22.

The sharpest bit from Luke 22 is v.36. In the NIV Jesus says, “But now if you have a purse, take it, and also a bag; and if you don’t have a sword, sell your cloak and buy one.” Generations since have not known quite what to do with what Jesus says about swords. On the one hand, we have the vast majority of Jesus’s words – and all his actions – that point in the direction of pacifism, of not using swords. Reading the Book of Acts and the rest of the New Testament the first generation certainly doesn’t look like “sword people.” The Chosen adds the line, “Ultimately your protection comes from above” to point back in this direction. On the other hand, we have the human tendency toward violence. We want to use swords (or better yet, in our day, guns) to defend ourselves. When we hear Jesus saying, “Sell your cloak so you can afford a weapon for self-defense,” we feel justified in our inclination.

John 2 is also featured in this episode. First, the climax is Jesus “cleansing the temple.” Though it likely happened once, and that once in the week leading up to his crucifixion, John puts it at the beginning, in Jesus first trip (first during his ministry) to Jerusalem. There is also a return to the story of Thomas. We have flashbacks to Thomas and his girlfriend packing up their wares to serve wine at the wedding in Cana, the first story in John 2. Those flashbacks set us up for Thomas’s confrontations with that girlfriend’s parents.

One of the strengths of the visual format is showing how big the temple business was. It took huge amounts of work to keep the sacrificial machinery going. Any disruption in the money changing and animal buying would put a kink in the flow of activity.

Caiaphas, the high priest, is a major focus of the episode. In his conversation with Herod we see that he has received a revelation from God and is staking his action on that revelation. We see that revelation in John 11. He’s been told that it’s “Necessary for one man to die for the nation.” Caiaphas is absolutely sure that he understands this revelation. Here’s Jesus, a false Messiah, causing a big ruckus in Jerusalem. Pilate has threatened Caiaphas – it’s his job to keep the peace, to prevent riots. If the Romans have to send in the troops to put down a riot, the people will certainly suffer. Caiaphas is sure that wants him to lead the saving of his nation by doing away with Jesus the messianic pretender.

A simple reading of history shows that Caiaphas’s being absolutely sure of himself yet absolutely wrong is not a rare thing. We seem to take such stances frequently.

By the end of the episode everyone seems convinced Jesus has gone mad. Caiaphas is hardened in his interpretation of the revelation. The crowds are stunned. Judas thinks Jesus has blown his opportunity to play the crowds into crowning him king.

Posted in Bible, Jesus, The Chosen | Tagged , , | Leave a comment

A non-Hauerwasian Interlude

Last week we looked at this paragraph in Stanley Hauerwas’s essay, “Discipleship as a Craft, Church as a Disciplined Community.”

For example, one of the great problems facing liberal and conservative churches alike is that their membership has been schooled on the distinction between public and private morality. Liberal and conservative alike assume that they have a right generally to do pretty much what they want, as long as what they do does not entail undue harm to others. The fact that such a distinction is incoherent even in the wider political society does little to help us challenge an even more problematic character in relationship to the church. Yet if salvation is genuinely social, then there can be no place for a distinction that invites us to assume, for example, that we have ownership over our bodies and possessions in a way that is not under the discipline of the whole church.[emphasis added]

Our culture is highly individualistic. Christians, live others in this culture, are formed by this individualism. Individualism is the air we breath. It just seems natural. Because we’re individualists, we easily assume that salvation is an individual thing: I “get saved.” I “go to heaven when I die.” I get to live in “MY mansion” in heaven. What we looked at in this most recent class was support for the belief, put forward without argument by Hauerwas, that “salvation is genuinely social.” By looking at passages like Genesis 12, Exodus 19, 1 Peter 2, and especially Ephesians 2, we see that from the very beginning God’s objective is to have a people who are his very own. Being part of this people is part of what salvation is about.

HERE’S a link to the recording.

Posted in Bible, Christianity, Discipleship, Doctrine, Ecclesiology, Salvation, Stanley Hauerwas, Theology | Tagged , , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Hauerwas – “What Do You Mean ‘We’ Kemosabe?”

The essay we’ve been looking at, “Discipleship as a Craft, Church as a Disciplined Community,” was written with a particular audience in mind. He writes,

In this respect it is interesting to note how we—that is, those of us in mainstream traditions–tend to think about the loss of membership by mainstream churches and the growth of so-called conservative churches. Churches characterized by compassion and care no longer are able to retain membership, particularly that of their own children, whereas conservative churches that make moral conformity and/or discipline their primary focus continue to grow. Those of us in liberal churches tend to explain this development by noting that people cannot stand freedom, and therefore, in a confusing world devoid of community, seek authority. Conservative churches are growing, but their growth is only a sign of pathology.

The group I’m leading through this essay are members of my church, a Global Methodist congregation. We think of ourselves as a “conservative” church, an “other” to the audience Hauerwas is addressing. We feel like his “we” doesn’t include us. The readers of The Christian Century in 1991 make up an audience different from our church – and likely also different from readers of that magazine today. But there are other complications as well.

Even those of us who reckon ourselves to be “conservative” in American churches think and act like “liberals,” valuing authentic freely made decisions by individuals above all else. None of us like being told what to do. We easily come back with the juvenile, “You’re not the boss of me.” His observation here is that churches that maintain a form of authority (better, discipline) are the churches that are growing. This has been true for most of the past forty years, but it’s unclear if this is still the case. My own guess is that the form of church life he advocates in this essay is good and necessary, but not sufficient. We still need a move of God lest we entrust ourselves to method.

Hauerwas speaks of conservative churches as focusing on “moral conformity.” While there is often a message of moral conformity in such churches, it is an illusion to think that messages of moral conformity do not play a role in nonconservative churches. Instead, there is a difference of moral vision, a different conception of the goods to be pursued.

At the end of the discussion we begin a discussion of Hauerwas’s later line, “Yet if salvation is genuinely social…” on the assumption that given the individualism of our culture and of American Christianity, the idea of salvation being social will not be obvious to all.

HERE’S a recording of our conversation.

Posted in Bible, Christianity, Discipleship, Discipline, Doctrine, Ecclesiology, Gospel, Jesus, Liberalism, Stanley Hauerwas, Theology | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Hauerwas – Minds Worth Making Up?

We continued our discussion of Stanley Hauerwas’s essay from The Christian Century (1991), “Discipleship as a Craft, Church as Disciplined Community.” We spent most the time talking about our culture’s infatuation with autonomous individualism and how that infatuation shows up in church. Hauerwas uses the conclusion of Dead Poets Society to make his point.

He says,

Such a view of ethics [what we see in our culture, circa 1991] can appear quite anticonventional, but even the anticonventional stance gains its power by appeal to what anyone would think upon reflection. This can be nicely illustrated in terms of the recent movie, The Dead Poets Society. It is an entertaining, popular movie that appeals to our moral sensibilities. The movie depicts a young and creative teacher battling what appears to be the unthinking authoritarianism of the school as well as his students’ (at first) uncomprehending resistance to his teaching method. The young teacher, whose subject is romantic poetry, which may or may not be all that important, takes as his primary pedagogical task helping his students think for themselves. We watch him slowly awaken one student after another to the possibility of their own talents and potential. At the end, even though he has been fired by the school, we are thrilled as his students find the ability to stand against authority, to think for themselves.

Our culture assumes there are two options: either we “think for ourselves” or we “mindlessly give in to authority.” The first is obviously the right thing in our culture. That we should think for ourselves is true; that thinking for ourselves means thinking by ourselves, is a profound mistake.

The ethic of “thinking for ourselves” is related to the ethic of “being countercultural.” The culture, or to use a word we see in scripture, the “world,” is something we Christians differentiate ourselves from. We resist its guidance. There are two big challenges with this. First, all of us are in the world, being formed by the world. Second, the world is not monolithic. We can be counter to one part of culture while in complete captivity to another.

He continues:

This movie seems to be a wonderful testimony to the independence of spirit that democracies putatively want to encourage. Yet I can think of no more conformist message in liberal societies than the idea that students should learn to think for themselves. What must be said is that most students in our society do not have minds well enough trained to think. A central pedagogical task is to tell students that their problem is that they do not have minds worth making up. That is why training is so important, because training involves the formation of the self through submission to authority that will provide people with the virtues necessary to make reasoned judgment.

Hauerwas stomps on cultural orthodoxy here. How can we as Christian leaders have our minds formed – and contribute to the forming of others – so our minds can be relied upon to think well for ourselves? What he says here about “training” is essential – and we know it’s essential in other domains of life. Hauerwas is going to want to make these same claims about students in church, in Christian settings.

The church’s situation is not unlike the problems of what it means to be a teacher in a society shaped by an ethos that produces movies like The Dead Poets Society. Determined by past presuppositions about the importance of commitment for the living of the Christian life, we have underwritten a voluntaristic conception of the Christian faith, which presupposes that one can become a Christian without training. The difficulty is that once such a position has been established, any alternative cannot help appearing as an authoritarian imposition.

The simple “decision to follow Jesus” is a good starting point. That alone, however, won’t result in our being Christian disciples.

HERE’S the audio of our discussion.

Posted in Bible, Christianity, Culture, Discipleship, Ecclesiology, Stanley Hauerwas, Theology | Tagged , , , , | Leave a comment

The Chosen, Season 5 Episode 1

We’re back to watching The Chosen on Wednesday nights. Here are a few thoughts & observations from episode 1.

The biblical parts of the episode (as opposed to the imaginative parts) are mostly drawn from John 12, 16, and a bit of 17. The episode opens with Jesus talking to the disciples in the Upper Room and segues back to his Triumphal Entry a few days before. The disciples are alternating between feeling absolutely sure they know what’s happening to total incomprehension. Jesus, knowing exactly what lies ahead, doesn’t project the level of excitement the disciples do. The happiest we see him is when he stumbles into a betrothal ceremony.

Jesus’ friends among the Jewish religious leaders confront him when he’s on the verge of entering Jerusalem. They don’t think anything good will come from what he’s about to do. They fear for his safety. The biblical symbolism accompanying Jesus – the donkey he’s riding, the palm branches and cries of “Hosanna” – are speaking more loudly than he himself is. These guys sincerely wanted to help Jesus. I wonder how often we sincerely want to help Jesus but, like them, miss the point.

No one looks more excited than Judas. He is absolutely sure this is the time Jesus will openly claim the kingship.

The filmmakers get something right about the relationship between Pilate and Caiaphas: Pilate’s big concern was that there be no riots. Whatever else Caiaphas did, he needed to keep the peace.

There is a small group of anti-Jesus people who have arrived in Jerusalem shortly after Jesus and his band. They are absolutely sure Jesus is a false prophet who is leading the people astray. They are convinced that in opposing Jesus they are doing God’s work. I was reminded of Saul in Acts 9 “breathing out murderous threats.”

Posted in Bible, Jesus, The Chosen, Uncategorized | Tagged , , , | Leave a comment

Jesus vs. Mammon

Mammon (an ancient god of money/wealth) says, “You are somebody based on on your wealth or capacity for gaining wealth.” Jesus says, “I love you and bought you with my blood.” Though rarely mentioned by name these days, Mammon is still popular in our culture.

Posted in Consumerism, Discipleship, Jesus | Tagged , , , , , | Leave a comment

Tonight’s Sky

Posted in Nature, photography | Tagged , , | Leave a comment

Failure of “Liberalism” in Texarkana?

I see our town has made the OPED page of the NY Times. I see many scholars quoted (& I’ve read many of their books and value their perspectives), but I don’t see that they talked to anyone in Texarkana, whether in Bowie or Miller County.

I’ve lived in Texarkana for three years now (and have lived in the area in the past, going back nearly 40 years). I like this area. I see lots of progress and growth in Texarkana – and feel the pain (try I-30 sometime!) that growth brings. I see the dedication of city and community leaders. The big projects mentioned in the piece (and they miss the funding that went to our new airport) sound like good news for the community. But do we all experience all these projects in their fullness?

A generation ago the political slogan was, “It’s the economy, stupid!” The premise of Edsall’s piece is that since the Biden administration steered so much money, so many resources to the Texarkana area, residents ought to be grateful and give them votes. That’s not how either “the economy” or politics work.

Let’s say that a majority of voters in the region even know that all these projects are happening AND that it was “the Biden administration” more than their Republican representatives and senators bringing the largesse. Sure, imagining most know that is a leap – and a sure work of imagination. Even so, when does this take place? Are the projects fully up and running? Are members of the community experiencing them for themselves – and experiencing them as good things?

‘The economy” doesn’t happen instantaneously. Sure, politicians need to keep the focus on themselves to keep their ratings up and to get elected next time around, but the actions they take don’t immediately demonstrate their full results. And what do we mean by “the economy?” Do we mean the statistics and numbers we see on the business page and headline news? Do we mean what’s happening nationally? Do we mean what’s happening to our own jobs and finances?

Is the reason local voters go for Republicans over Democrats primarily economic? If so, which aspect of the economy are they voting on? Can the voters be bought? If they can be bought, do those doing the buying spend the time to find out what kind of buy out voters are looking for?

If I were a Democrat I’d get up close and personal with the voters. I’d ask, “What are you looking for? What is it about my brand that has caused my part to lose you over the past generation? What can we do to win you back?” Maybe the voters understand their reason for shifting to the Republicans. Maybe they can articulate their reasons. Maybe they’ll even tell the truth when asked by the opposing party.

I like the idea of elected leaders (on all levels) looking farther ahead than just the next opinion poll or election. I like to see them asking, “What is good for the country, for my region? How can I discern that good with my fellow citizens so I’m neither lording it over them with my superior wisdom nor pandering to their current desires?” I realize that our current political marketplace doesn’t reward that kind of thinking. That’s depressing (but not new).

Coming back home, I’ll say again that I appreciate our local leaders. I see them leading our city well. It’s not an easy job – and often a thankless job. Over the long haul, say, the next 20 to 30 years, I expect Texarkana to be much improved for all citizens. That improvement requires all of us to share in the work.

Posted in Culture, Current events, Economics, Politics | Tagged , , | Leave a comment

Thinking about BLS Statistical Reports

BLS reporting has been in the news lately. I only took one statistics class in college, so I recognize my limitations. Nonetheless, I have some “meta” questions:

Are “good” statistical reports ones that clearly “show my team’s policy to be right”/”show the other team’s policy to be wrong?” Or are “good” reports those that most accurately DESCRIBE economic reality? Given the way humans work, there is ample reason to assume these two approaches to defining a “good” report are not necessarily the same thing.

A follow up question, following closely on the first. Do we WANT “good” reports? If I were in charge of economic policy and could demonstrate some cause and effect relationships between a statistical report and the policies my team was enacting, I would seek to learn from that report so I could adjust our policies appropriately.

Knowing that every policy has near, medium, and long term effects, AND knowing that every report of this large complex system we call “The Economy” (or even the subset called “The Labor Market”) is only an approximation, I know there are always limits on my knowledge.

If I operated on the alternative understanding of what makes a report “good” and cared (publicly at least) only that it made my team look good or the other team look bad, then I if I were an objectivist in the sense of believing that the world is the way it is whether I like it or not, I would have to live with the fact that reality may come back and bite me someday. If I were a subjectivist, i.e., if I believed my beliefs about the world MADE the world the way I believed it to be, then, Hey – I could believe whatever I wanted with no consequences.

Scott Lincicome, an economist who knows way more than I do on the subject, has SOME THOUGHTS. (The image above is from Lincicome’s piece)

Posted in Culture, Economics, Epistemology, Market, Politics, Wisdom | Tagged , , , , , , , , | Leave a comment