A Difference

One of the books I’m reading now is John Stackhouse’s Making the Best of It: Following Christ in the Real World. He quotes David Martin as saying,

“If I wanted to dramatize it I would point out that Mohammed was a warrior and a family man whereas Jesus was neither. Again notice that Islam sanctifies a holy city and is about territory whereas primitive Christianity is not. Indeed, for the early Christians Jerusalem was abandoned to desolation. The connection which underpins these differences is the link between the blood tie as realized in the family and land, possessions and violence. Christianity rejects the social logic embodied in genealogy, biological reproduction, and land, and attempts to set up spiritual and non-violent brotherhoods and sisterhoods outside that powerful nexus.”

Stackhouse recognizes that, as Martin says, this is a dramatized account. While Jesus clearly relativized family connections (in terms of biological kinship), the concern for biological family was edging its way back into Christianity fairly early. We can also see, unfortunately, that the history of Christians, once they got into power, made the faith look like something concerned with territory.

For me, the strength of this way of differentiating Christianity and Islam is that there is material internal to the Christian tradition, and in particular, material identified with Jesus himself, that allows us to critique and relativize the common human propensity to center on biological kinship, value the holding of territory, and using violence to make sure things turn out well. For you who are scholars of Islam: What resources are available within Islam to relativize these attitudes?

This entry was posted in Clash of Civilizations, Culture, Islam. Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to A Difference

  1. Earlier today I read this quote of Rowan Williams:

    There may be little love, even little generosity, in Clark’s bedding of Sarah, but Sarah has discovered that her body can be the cause of happiness to her and to another. It is this discovery which most clearly shows why we might want to talk about grace here. Grace, for the Christian believer, is a transformation that depends in large part on knowing yourself to be seen in a certain way: as significant, as wanted.

    Together with this post, I’ve gotten some great insights today, thanks!

  2. That’s not the quote I thought I cut. This is:
    Christian faith has its beginnings in an experience of profound contradictoriness. [So the church should proclaim] a hidden God, who does not uncover his will in a straight line of development, but fully enters into a world of confusion and ambiguity and works in contradictions.

  3. rheyduck says:

    I was wondering how that first quote fit. I figured I must have moved too many boxes of GS cookies or something.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s