The Price of Success?

Is it our national ECDD program (“Every Child Dumbed Down,” more commonly known as “No Child Left Behind”) that has warped our children to equate success with getting the right answers on a test? Or did the attitude precede that – success is making A’s, and you make A’s by getting right answers?

There’s nothing wrong with right answers. The problem comes when our quest (obsession?) for success prevents us from trying anything that we don’t know in advance that we can succeed at. “No, I’m going to skip the AP version of that class so I can be sure and pass.” (Or for the GPA hounds, “So I can get an A.”) Where’s the adventure in that? But maybe we don’t want adventure unless we can be sure and succeed at it.

I’ve done some sports bashing over the years – complaining about how sports has, for some, become a new national religion. Maybe in my haste I was throwing out the baby with the bathwater. Maybe the academic side needs to imbibe some of the “Citius, Altius, Fortius” (the Olympic motto – “Faster, Higher, Stronger”) attitude. That’s sure better than just doing enough to get by (what our state proficiency tests seem to be requiring).

We – the academic types – can also profit from the team aspect of sports. What can we do to get to the point where we think, “We will do better when I work harder and exert myself.” A team is made up of people of varying abilities and skills who all work together, for both the common good and individual good of the participants. Can we encourage, challenge and provoke each other? Can we dare (not letting the miscreants steal the word) each other to go beyond what each thinks he or she can do?

Posted in Education | 2 Comments

Criticizing My Baby

My children range in age from almost teenage to over twenty. My baby, however, was conceived in the early 1980s, first came to light in 1998, and went public in 2002. Here’s a picture of my baby:

Recovery of Doctrine

Haven’t seen many purple babies? Oh well.

Some babies are able to grow up and live a normal life. My baby is now old enough to be getting some criticism. As the father, it’s sometimes hard to hear criticism. But as a father, I also know that criticism means people are paying attention to my baby. It’s criticism that will help my baby grow up and mature.

Right now I’m reading Kevin Vanhoozer’s The Drama of Doctrine: A Canonical Linguistic Approach to ChristianVanhoozer Theology. Vanhoozer’s written a pile of books – to my one – and his  baby is not only more brightly colored than mine, it’s also much longer and more detailed.  I’ve  read almost a hundred pages so far, not enough to make a fair judgment yet. I can say that I like much of what  I see in it.He clearly picks up some of the ideas I mention or hint at and develops them with much more detail. I’m not bothered by that (a) because mine was a revision of my dissertation and it was thus more limited in its conception, and (b) I didn’t want to go into that much detail. Sometimes adding great detail is a virtue. Sometimes its just more detail. At the least he’s better at the detail than I am.

Hermeneutics of DoctrineI just discovered a couple of weeks ago that Anthony Thiselton argues with me in his latest book, The Hermeneutics of Doctrine. I first read Thiselton back in seminary. He’s a real heavyweight when it comes to theological hermeneutics. I haven’t gotten my copy of his book yet so I don’t know what he has to say about my baby (and its arguments) yet, but I’m just happy he read it and thinks it worth arguing with.

Posted in Books, Theology | Leave a comment

Stepping Out

I’ve taught on spiritual gifts many times over the past twenty years. One of the tools commonly used in such teaching is what we call a “Spiritual Gifts Inventory.”(Here’s a sample of an online inventory.) The theory is that by filling out the inventory – often over a hundred questions – you can identify your spiritual gifts. I haven’t used inventories much lately because I’ve noticed they’re better at identifying what you like to do then what God has equipped you to do. If it’s something you’ve tried before, they’ll pick it out. Otherwise, they’ll likely miss it.

Sometimes God’s call is a direct line with what we’ve been doing – direct from our current point of view. But often it isn’t. While Moses had a desire to be used by God, his calling at the burning bush was not in line with his experience up to that point. This is why when I teach on spiritual gifts I also teach that while knowing our gifts is important, it’s more important to obey God. It is never an adequate response to God’s calling to say, ‘But God, that’s not my spiritual gift!”

God’s call in our lives has several motivations:

  1. God’s call is first and foremost an expression of love. God loves us enough to involve us in what he is doing.

  2. God’s call is to join in kingdom work, i.e., accomplishing his agenda for the salvation of all creation. The work to which we are called is important – it counts for something. It’s not mere busy work or hoop jumping. For some reason God is not content to do all the work himself – he wants to involve his people.

  3. Responding to God’s call requires faith even while it builds our faith. When I go work out, it takes some strength to lift a weight. As I lift that weight more and more, I get stronger. In the same way, our stepping out in response to God’s call requires faith. But as we step out, as we go on adventure with God, our faith grows in the process.

  4. God wants us to trust him more than we trust ourselves, our resources, and our capacities. One way Paul puts this is that God shows his strength in our weakness. If we invest all our time and energy in making ourselves strong, we leave little room for God. Why trust God when we can trust ourselves? I think that’s why God habitually calls people to do what thy can’t do by themselves.

Have you tried stepping out in faith? A good starting point is to simply say, “Lord, what is my next step?” You don’t need to know tomorrow’s or next year’s step – just your next step. Then listen to what God says. Trust God to show his love by involving you in what he’s doing.

Posted in Ministry, Spirituality | 1 Comment

Sharing Jesus

Spengler writes in his column in the Asia Times, in response to the conversion of journalist Magdi Allam from Islam to Catholic Christianity:

Muslim traditional society cannot withstand the depredations of globalized culture, and radical Islam arises from a despairing nostalgia for the disappearing past. Why would Muslims trade the spiritual vacuum of Islam for the spiritual sewer of Dutch hedonism? The souls of Muslims are in agony. The blandishments of the decadent West offer them nothing but shame and deracination.

Before 9/11 there was a movement in the US among some politically conservative Christians to make common cause with Muslims in reaction to what they saw as the decline of morality in our general culture. Al Qaeda and other extremist groups within Islam were unable to distinguish between the West and Christianity, thinking, apparently, that since the US is morally corrupt and the US is a Christian nation, then Christianity itself must be corrupt. It’s the same kind of judgment some of us make when we look at the evils of Al Qaeda, recognize Al Qaeda is a Muslim organization, and assume that Islam must be evil.

Since 9/11 some Christians have decided that we need to back Western culture “right or wrong,” so we can present a united front, defending “our way of life” against Islam. I believe that is a mistake. It is not our calling as Christians to:

  • Fight for Western supremacy
  • Fight against Islam

Our calling as Christians is to stand up for Jesus. We find our identity in Christ. Our security is in Christ, not the US constitution, the US armed forces, our Western heritage. It’s Jesus. From the standpoint of life in Christ we assess our host culture (2 Cor. 10:3-5), finding its strengths and weaknesses, its goods and its evils.

If we are going to regain the West (if we ever really had it), it’ll be by following Jesus. If we’re going to win the Muslims – either as friends or by attracting them to Jesus – it’ll be by following Jesus.

Posted in Al Qaeda, Clash of Civilizations, Current events, Evangelism, Globalization, Islam | 1 Comment

Moderating Islam

Ever since 11 September 2001 people in the West have been searching for “moderate Islam.” A couple of days ago I briefly mentioned Akbar S. Ahmed’s book, Islam Under Siege: Living Dangerously in a Post-Honor World, with particular reference to his revival of Ibn Khaldun’s concept of asabiyya. Ahmed strikes me as one any but the most Islamophoic would consider a moderate.

Ahmed believes that features of modernity, globalization and urbanization in particular, have put a strain on Islam. While existing in traditional societies, the families, clans and tribes were held together by asabiyya. Now that these social entities are being torn asunder, some among them feel the need to re-assert the cohesion of asabiyya, what Ahmed calls hyper-asabiyya. It is this paranoid and frenetic quest for a lost cohesion, that results in extremism and terrorism.

Some have observed the similarity between asabiyya and what modern scholars call social capital. Bowling Alone by Robert Putnam, has been my main source for learning about social capital. He identifies two types of social capital. Bonding social capital, akin to asabiyya, is an agent of social cohesion. It is the glue that holds a community together. Bridging social capital, working outward instead of inward, seeks out connections with other groups or to draw outsiders in.

Here in the USA, when we hear people complaining about how illegal immigrants (or immigrants in general) are diluting the sense of what it means to be an American, we are hearing an assertion that bonding social capital is lacking, or rather, that it is breaking down on a national level in favor of ethnic expressions. What is it that makes me an American? I don’t care, I’m a hispanic/white/black/turkish/italian – that’s enough for my identity. The next step, that would take us in the direction of the break down Ahmed sees, we in those who feel utterly alone. Perhaps through something like hyper-asabiyya they turn to gangs for their sense of identity.

What I see lacking in the segments of Muslim culture where hyper-asabiyya reigns (and no, I’m not an expert on Muslim culture, so correct me if I’m wrong), is bonding social capital worked to the exclusion on bridging social capital. A moderate Islam – like, perhaps, a moderate Americanism – would be concerned not only for in-group health and cohesion, but would see that health partly consisting in relationships with outsiders. Even when there is fear and fragmentation, making room for the outward focus of bridging social capital would help break down the harshness of hyper-asabiyya.

Posted in Clash of Civilizations, Islam, Social Capital | 1 Comment

A Church with vision

I like learning from a wide variety of people. In just the past couple of days I’ve posted comments on what I’m learning from a Pakistani Muslim college professor and two leadership types from out west. Another person I’ve been learning from lately is Perry Noble, pastor of New Spring church in Anderson, South Carolina. Perry and I are very different. He’s a southern redneck by upbringing. Though I was born in California, my home town is in Illinois – though I’ve never lived there, since my dad was in the Navy while I was growing up. He’s a baptist (though apparently not very well behaved) and I’m a methodist. He talks about making a 790 on his SAT and I have advanced degrees. His church was planted less than ten years ago and already has thousands, mine is 150 years old and we have about 200. Sounds like a big difference, doesn’t it?

But what we have in common, I believe, overcomes the differences. Here are the most important things I see us having in common. 1. We’re centered on Jesus. 2. We’re called (to put it mildly) to build up the Body of Christ so that more people might come to faith in Jesus.

I like Perry’s passion for Jesus – and passion for the people Jesus died to save. I like his sarcasm. I work hard quenching my sarcastic streak, but I still feel it on the inside. I listen to his Sunday messages from time to time, listened to his presentations at New Spring’s recent Unleash Conference, and read his blog. If you insist on only learning from people who are entirely civilized, prim and proper, forget Perry Noble. If you are – or want to be – passionate for Jesus and for people, you might consider taking a peek.

Perry recently had a post entitled, “15 signs that you (or your church) lack vision.” Here are his points with my comments (Perry’s words are in bold):

#15 – No one is ever challenged to radically rearrange their lives to be a part of what God is doing. In my church I get the idea that it’s easy to take “radical life re-arrangement” as something only for pastors and their families. I really want my people to get a vision of what God wants to do in Pittsburg, Camp County, Texas – and to the ends of the earth. Then, having seen that vision, catch God’s passion to rescue people through Jesus and join in the work. But too often we settle for playing church. “Good sermon, pastor.” I don’t care if you think it’s a good sermon. Is God speaking to you? Will you respond? Will you say yes to him? Will you take his agenda as your own?

#14 – God hasn’t asked you to give something up. I’ve had to give up living in a house of my choice and in a community of my choice. But God has blessed me here so I’m ok.

#13 – Everyone in your church is perfect. (If you are truly reaching lost people then you will discover that ministry is messy.) We’ve progressed to the point that we have some imperfect people, but I’d like to see us get to the place that we revel in having them around, and love them no matter what. A truly healthy church will have plenty of sinners around.

#12 – Nothing in regards to how you lead has changed in the past year. I’m learning all the time. I feel like I have so much more to learn.

#11 – When your youth group wants to do something you make them have a bake sale in front of Wal Mart–but when your senior adults want to do something the church covers the cost; after all, they are tithers! (And that same church will wonder why “the youth don’t come to church anymore.”) We support the youth ministry, but I’m don’t think we do it to the degree that they always feel supported and valued.

#10 – You always find something wrong with ministries that are seeing fruit. I want more fruit! We’re too happy doing what we’ve always done. I know my conservative bent gets in the way.

#9 – You can do everything you have in front of you WITHOUT the help of God AND others. My constant prayer for the church is that he would do something in our midst that is only explainable as the work of God – so that outsiders will be attracted to Jesus. I pray at the same time that we will let him do that, that we won’t insist on having all the resources in sight, in the bank, or in our pockets before we step out and obey.

#8 – You spend more time on other churches websites than you do reading your Bible. Conviction time for me. I need more time in the word.
#7 – You think the answer to every problem is, “If we just had more money.” God’s blessed us mightily in terms of finances in the past few years – well beyond my wimpy expectations. Too often I think in terms of what they say about investments, “Past performance is no guarantee of future performance.” God is faithful – you’d think I’d’ve learned that by now.

#6 – No one has ever left your church. A few have, but I think it’s the wrong people. I’m probably too “nice.”

#5 – You continually call other churches begging them for money. Hey! I’m doing ok on this one!

#4 – You allow people with money to dictate the way you spend your time and the direction of the church. I think we’re ok on this one too. I want to listen to the people who are listening to and obeying God.

#3 – When you go to a conference and come back and announce “we are changing everything” because you have received INSPIRATION not REVELATION. I’ve been to enough conferences over the years that I’m mostly cynical. If I could get the rest of my leadership to go, it might be different. Too many times what I brought back was “crazy preacher ideas,” and people just humored me, knowing reality would knock me down soon enough. I’ve learned the hard way that I need to listen to God, not just the latest expert.

#2 – You’ve never spent sleepless nights wondering, “How in heck are we going to do this? Seriously, I told our church we were going to do WHAT?” Plenty of sleepless nights, plenty of agonizing over responding to God and seeing him move.
#1 – You worry more about keeping the people in your church happy then you do about pleasing God and speaking the truth. I think most of our leaders are primarily desiring to see God happy. We still have much to learn in regard to how that actually works out, but I think we’re on the right track.

Posted in Leadership, Ministry, Perry Noble, Uncategorized | 4 Comments

A Jealous God

I just finished reading Akbar S. Ahmed’s Islam Under Siege: Living Dangerously in a Post-Honor World, a book well worth reading. Ahmed attributes much of what we in the West see as extremism in the Muslim world as originating in the breakdown of asibiyya, a concept of social solidarity he derives from the writings of Ibn Khaldun. Here’s one quote from the book:

“Asibiyya, which presupposed exclusivity, glorifies the group. But God while universal and generous in His attitude toward mankind is nonetheless possessive about praise. God certainly does not approve of sharing praise with rivals called ‘tribe’ or ‘nation.’ By conflating God and the group, leaders of the community employ an effective strategy: The honor of the group can now be defended in the name of God. As a consequence we see the emergence of a frenetic, distorted and dangerous form of asibiyya – one I am calling hyper-asibiyya. Thus God’s vision of justice and compassion are set aside for the group’s need for honor and revenge. To unlock the conundrum of hyper-asibiyya anthropologists who study communities and how notions of honor affect behavior need to be in discussion with theologians whose business is to attempt to understand God. One without the other would only comprehend part of the picture.”

While it’s easy to see how some Muslim groups have conflated the sense of God’s honor and the honor of their group, it looks like Americans – presumed Christians – are not off the hook here.  Muslim experience of social breakdown and fear of its consequences lead to disastrous consequences. Our fear of terrorism (or of Muslims – or immigrants) will also likely lead to disastrous consequences – if fear is our primary motivator.

Posted in Clash of Civilizations, Islam, Politics | 2 Comments

Starfish and the Spider, part 3

Brafman & Becstrom, authors of The Starfish and the Spider, offer some “New Rules for the Game.” Here are their rules along with my comments.

New Rules to the Game

  • Diseconomies of scale – larger is not always better: Bill Easum has been saying for a while that the era of the Mega-Church will come to an end before too long. I’m not enough of a futurist to assess this claim, but I know many churches continue to grow huge – some to several thousand in just a few years. They are reaching people for Christ and doing powerful ministry. I wouldn’t want to be in their place, with debt and investments in BIG if the day comes when the masses tire of BIG and decide they want small. As things stand now, even the BIG churches preach the necessity of small – of making ways for people to connect face to face and do life together.

  • The Network Effect – New members increase the value of the network. I believe that God brings people into the church – adds them to the Body – so that we can be healthier and better achieve Kingdom purposes. Churches in particular benefit from new folks, bringing in their new networks of relationships and broader experience.

  • The Power of Chaos. Most people out there seem to hate chaos, preferring certainty and predictability. I’m a P – as in INTP – so I have a fairly high tolerance for chaos. A few years ago when I was reading a book on chaos theory, I learned that when medical researchers were studying the regularity of heart rhythm, they expected to find that the more regular a person’s rhythm, the healthier the person. They discovered, however, that extreme regularity could be a sign of unhealth. A normal healthy heart follows a chaotic pattern. I can imagine that a healthy church might also.

  • Knowledge at the Edge. Everyone in the church, however marginal, has knowledge needed for our wise fulfillment of our mission. If we only listen to the official leaders we will lose out. As leaders, however, we need to find ways to harness and discipline that knowledge.

  • Everyone wants to contribute. I know that I want to make the world a better place. I don’t have much direct impact on the world as a whole, but I do have the capacity to work for the good in various local institutions: my family, my church, my city, the local schools. I like to work on the assumption that other people think that way also.

  • Beware the Hydra response. Dangers are multi-headed and complex. I’ve seen that in church, yes.

  • Catalysts rule. Here’s my paraphrase: People who can energize and equip others to join in the mission of the church are immensely more powerful than some powerful leader at the top who tries to do or control everything.

  • The Values are the Organization. In Built to Last Collins & Porras talk about how the best organizations they studied were absolutely clear on their mission and absolutely flexible on how they pursued it. As we find our identity and security in Jesus, take his mission as our own, our organization will be more than just organizational structure, but can become an agent of the Kingdom of God.

  • Measure, Monitor and Manage. Pay attention to what’s going on around us. Ask questions about it. “Are we there yet?”

  • Flatten or be flattened. Hierarchical organizations will be relatively weaker to the degree they are more hierarchical. Learn from the Starfish or be squished. This is the message of their book. I’m still convinced that while this is valuable, clarity regarding our mission is even more important.

Posted in Books, Leadership, United Methodism | 1 Comment

Starfish And Spider, part 2

Continuing my interaction with the book, The Starfish and the Spider, I’d like to see what relevance their discussion of discerning the one from the other might have for the United Methodist church. The authors give these questions to ask when trying to tell spider from starfish:

  1. Is there a person in charge? The UMC as a whole has no person in charge. The General Conference, and the General Conference alone is supposed to speak for us. In the Annual Conferences, however, the bishop is in charge, in the District the Superintendent, and in the local church – to some degree – the pastor is seen as being in charge. In each of these cases the actual degree of control varies from setting to setting, partly determined by the nature and history of that setting, partly by the personality and style of the leader. My guess is that more of us like being in charge than ought to, partly because we think something along the lines of “If you want it done right, do it yourself.” We’re take charge kinds of people.

  2. Are there headquarters? Each Conference has a headquarters (at least in my experience), and we have various Boards and Agencies that in some ways serve as headquarters for the church. Personally, I feel a gap between Nashville and New York on the one hand, and the local church on the other.

  3. If you thump it on the head, will it die?The UMC is not vulnerable to thumping on the head – though it may well have been at some point in Wesley’s day (in the UK) or in Asbury’s day (in the USA). I don’t think our death is coming from the top.

  4. Is there a clear division of roles? We have a nearly absolute differentiation between clergy and laity. We have begun to speak in terms of spiritual gifts, but whether that will overcome our strict dichotomy, I don’t know. I have often heard people ask someone whether they have the proper authority to do what they are doing (or proposing to do). This sounds like a spider concern to me.

  5. If you take out a unit, is the organization harmed? We have enough units (at this stage) that taking out one won’t harm the organization. We’re in decline, but losing units (churches/members) seems to still be more of an effect than a cause.

  6. Are knowledge and power concentrated or distributed? We try to concentrate knowledge in our Seminaries, Boards and Agencies, and power in those Boards, Agencies, and key leaders. We need to do better at giving them away.

  7. Is the organization flexible or rigid? We’ve started talking about being flexible, but it’s hard to make the shift. Our Book of Discipline still reads like a mid-20th century bureaucratic manual.

  8. Can you count the employees or participants? We act (mistakenly, I believe) like counting all the employees/participants is a good thing.

  9. Are working groups funded by the organization or are they self-funded? Funding varies from level to level. Most Boards and Agencies are funded by the organization. Each local church is self-funding. Because of tax laws sub-organizations in the local church often are pressed to be centrally funded.

  10. Do working groups communicate directly or through intermediaries? In my (limited) experience most groups communicate through intermediaries. In the current Texas Annual Conference structure, we have so many new groups, and are pushing to do things in new ways, that we don’t know what we’re doing. The downside of that – from what I’ve seen – is that it means we just keep doing what we’ve always done, though with new names and titles pasted on.

Posted in Leadership, Local church, Ministry, United Methodism | Leave a comment

Church in Saudi Arabia?

Now that a Christian church has opened in Qatar, is it only a matter of time until a church is opened in Saudi Arabia? There are only a few million Christians there (officially, only the expatriates working there), so having a church (or churches) for them makes sense. But then again, maybe not:

Anwar Ashiqi, president of the Saudi centre for Middle East strategic studies, endorsed this view in an interview on the site of Arab satellite TV network, al-Arabiya on Thursday.

“I haven taken part in several meetings related to Islamic-Christian dialogue and there have been negotiations on this issue,” he said.

“It would be possible to launch official negotiations to construct a church in Saudi Arabia only after the Pope and all the Christian churches recognise the prophet Mohammed.”

“If they don’t recognise him as a prophet, how can we have a church in the Saudi kingdom?”

Some Christians have no trouble saying something like, “Sure, Mohammed was a prophet,” thinking that’s the way to be open-minded and tolerant. But how does one become a Muslim? My understanding is that becoming a Muslim is very easy. All you have to do is profess the basic confession of Islam, “There is no God but God and Mohammed is his prophet.” But if Christians say of Mohammed what Anwar Ashiqi wants them to say of him, won’t that make them into Muslims? As Christians, it’s already likely that they’re monotheists (“No God but God”), so that’s not a problem. But now they’re adding the rest, “And Mohammed is his prophet.” They won’t need to build any churches at all if all the Christians will just “recognize Mohammed,” i.e., become Muslims.

Am I missing something here? If I am, would Christians, Muslims, and modern Western liberals explain what I’m missing the same way? If you have a different take, let me know.

Posted in Islam, Theology | Leave a comment