Kirbyjon Caldwell at the Gathering

This year’s Gathering (Texas Conference Pastors Retreat) began with a message from Kirbyjon Caldwell of Windsor Village UMC. Kirbyjon is always worth listening to. He began with a statistic about our current situation: The United Methodist Church is losing 73,000 worshipers each year. Considering a single institution in our church, one heavily weighted toward the older end of the age spectrum, he suggested in that in fourteen and a half years there would be no one left in UMW (United Methodist Women).

I don’t see how anyone could dispute this. Though my own congregation is doing better than some, when I see the high percentage of our highly committed and active folks are over 70, I’m forced to recognize that chances are against them being as active and committed in ten years.We have simply don an inadequate job reaching younger generations.

It’s time for United Methodists to wake up and change, he says. We’ve all heard it, “When you do what you’ve always done, you get what you’ve always got,” but we keep on doing what we’ve always done.

Our problem is that some of the things we’ve always done used to work. We keep doing them because they worked in our younger days. We grew attached to them. In many cases our actions declare that we’re more in love with our ways of following Jesus than we are with Jesus himself. In other cases we have identified key parts of our Christian identity as “things we’ve always done that no longer work” – preaching the bible, the doctrine of the Trinity, the resurrection of Jesus, evangelism, etc. While I understand the slogan, slogans do not make for well-finessed arguments.

Kirbyjon sees Bishop Huie’s leadership in the Texas Conference as one beacon of light in the denomination.

I agree with Kirbyjon, but I sometimes fear it might be too late. We have not yet broken the back of despair and resistance to change endemic to the system. The distrust that built up between pastors, churches and conference leadership over the years is still under the surface (ok, sometimes it’s under the surface, sometimes it’s way above the surface).

Kirbyjon turns to Jesus and John Wesley for some ideas for our future, seeing them as “masters at planting incremental changes in people which in turn lead to collective transformation.”

But they both used plenty of non-incremental change. When he cleansed the temple Jesus didn’t take out the pigeons one week, then after that change had been received come back for the lambs, and only later come back for the money changers. When Wesley began field preaching he didn’t make it there by inching away from the pulpit week by week.

From this beginning, Kirbyjon made two broad suggestions.

First, we need to change our Procedures and Practices to fit the needs of the community. John Wesley did this in the areas of education, health care and economic development. He noted that within our laity we have people who are experienced – more experienced than the clergy – in leading successful organizational transformation. We need to find ways to draw on their leadership, even, he suggested, find a way to bring them into episcopal leadership.

Our current system of guaranteed appointments – with their guaranteed pay checks encourage mediocrity.

The big question we need to ask: What changes must I make in my current ministry to turn things around?

We also need to work, secondly, on Preaching and Proclamation. Within this area of change we need to do a number of things.

First, someone needs to be accountable for the quality of our worship. When we’re accountable we will need to identify resistant leaders and “preach the hell out of them;” quit pitying their situations (Sure, church leadership in this age is tough. But it’s tough for everyone); and we need to “Set the table so that people want to come to church.”

Second, we need to be authentic. He told the story of Keith Kellow, one of the conference oldtimers who had hoped that the merger of the central conference in 1960 would have brought the energy and life of the black churches into the white churches. Instead he saw the black churches become too much like the often-dead white churches. He observed that while American culture will tolerate pornography, greed, lust, and the like, it won’t tolerate boring.

Third, we need to preach with authority. He quipped, “If you don’t preach well, then don’t preach long.” He also said we need to never preach a sermon with no Bible. John Wesley and Jesus were both scripture saturated – we must be also.

Fourth, we must cast a vision of the Christian life and the Gospel of Universal Redemption. We have tp preach hope to those with no hope.

Posted in Texas Annual Conference, United Methodism | 5 Comments

Letter to a Pilgrim

One of the phrases I’ve heard all my life is “If you want it done right, do it yourself.” I’ve seen the truth of it in much of my life. What amazes me is that God doesn’t think that way.

Rather than doing everything he wants done, God invites us to join in what he’s doing. That’s the third step of grace offered to us that I see in Ephesians. The first step is what we usually call “salvation by grace.” We see that in Eph. 2:8-9. We’re not saved by our resume, our pedigree or anything we do. All of salvation is by the grace of God offered in Jesus. It’s great news. But too often we stop there.

The second step of grace is in the second half of Eph. 2. We see there that the salvation offered in Christ is more than just a matter of individuals getting right with God. In addition to reconciling us with God, Jesus breaks down the wall between Gentile and Jew, or in more general terms, the walls that exist between people because of sin. Jesus came not only so that I could spend eternity with him, but so that we together could be his people now and forever. If we miss out on the loving fellowship and unity of the church, we miss out on the fulness of salvation in Jesus.

But there is a third step, found in Eph. 3. There we hear Paul say, “This grace was given me, to preach the unsearchable riches of Christ to the Gentiles.” Grace not only brings me into a healed relationship with God and a healed relationship with others, it also draws me (us) into God’s continuing activity. If I say, “Nah, that’s only for preachers and ‘full time Christian workers,’” I again miss out on the fulness of salvation found in Jesus.

You’ve had a big weekend. You’ve experienced God grace – perhaps in new ways or in refreshed old ways. Perhaps you’ve felt God’s claim on your life, saying something to you like, “Your my child, bought with the blood of my Son, mine for eternity.” That same Jesus also says, “As the Father has sent me, so I am sending you.”

Scary? Maybe. But it’s not an issue of “Ok, you’re saved, now here’s your work assignment, hop to it. Report in when you’re done.” No, in the same context where Jesus says, “As the Father has sent me, so I am sending you” he also says, “Receive the Holy Spirit.” There is no way to live the Christian life on our own. We need the Holy Spirit living within us.

We also need each other. Jesus doesn’t send us out as lone rangers, individuals out among the wolves. He sends us out together. As you follow Jesus, you’re never in it alone. Jesus says, “I will be with you to the very end of the age.” And he says that to the people around us as we travel together in his way.

Posted in Spirituality | Leave a comment

A Dry Brook

Today’s a normal Wednesday – prayer meeting & bible study in the morning (along with the requisite preparation), Rotary at noon, later picking up HRH at school, then cooking dinner since my wife will be running the church children’s program this afternoon. In the times between these events, I’ve been listening to bits and pieces of The Nines, a one day leadership event put on by Leadership Network and Catalyst.

One person I was able to hear in whole this morning was Steven Furtick. His nine minute talk (that’s how the Nines works) was about Elijah. God had sent Elijah out into the wilderness during a time of drought in Israel. For a good amount of time Elijah was able to get water from the Brook Cherith. But then the brook dried up.

If you’ve been around bible teaching for any length of time, you’ve probably encountered use of the metaphor of dryness. Once there was a flow, once there was life. Now we’re parched. We’re thirsty. We’re needy.

Furtick asked why the brook went dry. By extension, we would ask why we experience dryness in our lives. The first part of his answer was to observe that it was a drought after all. Brooks often dry up when there is no rain. It wasn’t that Elijah had done something wrong or that God was sending judgment on him. No, it was just the effect of events in the broader world.

But the dry brook gave Elijah a chance to move on – to go have his needs met elsewhere. Furtick suggested that sometimes as leaders we experience times of dryness, and in those times, God is enabling us to move on and find other sources that he has prepared for us.

So if we want to have – need to have – a fresh encounter with God we need to move, actually, physically move somewhere, relocate our residence? I don’t take that to be Furtick’s point. Instead, there are some things we are currently doing that we need to stop doing. There are some practices we are not now engaging in that we need to take up. We need to enter some new relationships and perhaps recontextualize some old ones.

Posted in Spirituality | Leave a comment

Success in ministry

Several years ago we had an after-school ministry for upper elementary aged children. By the time we stopped it, it looked like a whopping success. Our little small town church would have 40-50 kids, mostly not from our church, show up on Wednesday afternoons. Sounds great, doesn’t it?

But there at the end, it was mostly chaos. Our few volunteers lacked the energy to keep up with the kids. We felt a day was a success if no one had been seriously injured or broken anything. Did the kids learn anything? Hard to tell, since most of our time was spent working on behavior issues.

Our current after school ministries are much smaller. But they are also orderly enough that the kids can get something out of them.

The mistake we made earlier – and are still prone to make – is to think our primary focus should be on ministry to children and youth. In a declining church full of old people, it’s really easy to argue for that position. Despite our lack of younger folks, both locally and denominationally, I think seeing our ministry to children and youth as primary is a mistake. What we should see as primary is a discipling ministry with adults so that these adults will then be the doers of ministry with children and youth. Why?

A first reason to focus on adults is that parents have the primary responsibility to disciple their kids. Sure, it’s rare for parents to do that. We’ll teach them to hunt, fish, cook, drive, and other things of life. But do we teach them them to pray? To read and understand the bible? To share their faith with others? To interpret their lives and encounters with the world in terms of the Kingdom of God? Usually not. At least in many UM churches, many of the adults are too spiritually introverted to feel “comfortable” doing these things. Better leave these really important things to the professionals, i.e., the Sunday School teachers and church staff.

I know the temptation here. We on staff reason that if the parents aren’t doing it, we ought to. It’s too good a thing to leave undone. True. But we’re displacing the parent’s responsibility. They will still have to answer to God.

A second reason to have a primary focus on adults is pragmatic. Parents are the ones who have control over their lives. Sure, their control is relative, but compared to children and youth, their control is immense. If they want to go to worship on Sunday morning, for instance, all an adult has to do is get up on time, get ready and go. In this age when you get to church gatherings in a car, children are at the mercy of their parents. Parents have more power to bring children along than children have to bring parents along.

The major consequence for those of us who are in leadership is that our primary job is not performing functions. We don’t hire people to do what we currently think of as our primary ministries (even if we can’t find anyone who is willing). We hire people to invest in the lives of others who will then become the doers of those ministries. Perhaps once upon a time churches could afford to hire people to do all the ministry that needs to be done. Not any more. The people we hire need to be leaders, catalytic people, who develop others to do ministry.

Posted in church growth, Leadership, Local church, Ministry | 1 Comment

How’s Your Love Life?

The bible tells us that “we love because he first loved us.” While it is common to summarize the Old Testament as presenting a God of judgment and the New Testament as a God of love, such a characterization is not rooted in the facts. We see tremendous instances of God’s love in the Old Testament. (Have you read Zephaniah 3:17 lately? – “The LORD your God is with you, he is mighty to save. He will take great delight in you, he will quiet you with his love, he will rejoice over you with singing.”) We also see many words about judgment in the New. In both testaments, love is the root of God’s action.

We see the two, love and judgment, come together in various places. One in particular stands out. Romans 5:8 says, “God demonstrates his love toward us in this: While we were still sinners, Christ died for us.” Judgment says we’re sinners (a couple of verses later it uses a stronger word – “enemies of God.”). Love makes a judgment that the judgment of sinner is not the final word.

Ok, so God loves us. Or we might put it in some other words of John. It’s not just that God loves us, but that God is love. That starting point of our love lives is knowing this love of God.

“Knowing” is an interesting word, isn’t it. We go to school so we can know more. While knowing – having an intellectual grasp or understanding of – God’s love is a good thing, the more important kind of knowing is experiential. When I was a child I experienced my parents’ love before I even knew the word, much less understood the concept.

So let’s ask this, have you experienced God’s love? Let me refine that a bit more. Have you experienced God’s love as God’s love, in a way that you could say, “Yes, I have experienced God’s love, and here is an instance of such an experience.”

The more we come to know God’s love the more clearly we see the truth about ourselves (sinful, broken, lost, needy) and how that truth about ourselves, because of Jesus, is not the final truth about us. The love of God expressed in the life, death and resurrection of Jesus relativizes those truths about us, those words of judgment.

Have you received that gift of love? That’s what makes or breaks your love life.

Posted in Love, Spirituality | 1 Comment

Wanting It

Dan Dick has another good post at United Methodeviations. Talking about growing a church, he observes that mainline churches tend to go after the same group of people over and over again. We have trouble moving beyond the middle class folks just like us. He identifies other populations we should consider if we really want to grow our churches.

The first group, those of lower income and tending to have less in the way of formal education, are the primary group of non-church folk we have around here. We do a really poor job reaching them. Dick observes that churches in general are sometimes willing to do ministry to them, but since they have little to offer (think here of “money to support our ever more strained budgets”), we rarely want them to join us.

The folks I know in this group are often genuinely interested in Jesus. But the church – at least as we currently do it – is culturally distant from them. They feel like they don’t fit in. I think most of our folk would be happy to have them here, but I don’t think we’re willing to make many changes to accommodate them.

One tactic we keep talking about is what is popularly called “contemporary style worship.” In conversation with Dave Herman last week, we observed that neither of us had experienced much in the way of United Methodist “contemporary worship” that felt more recent (culturally speaking) than the 1970s. I suppose this is to be expected, since most of us in leadership have been so immersed in church culture for so long that we’re not open to any other ways of doing things.

But I find it curious for a couple of reasons. On the one hand, in our church, and in many others, there is at least an undercurrent of resistance to “contemporary worship.” One of the complaints I’ve heard is a fear that it will steal folks away from the already existing services. Yet on the other hand, we design our new services to so they’ll be attractive to the people we already have. Do you see the irony here?

My idea is to design a worship service that our current people don’t like, yet is culturally relevant to the people who are not now here. After all, we’ve already reached the people who are here (except maybe the younger generation who come as captives of their parents, who will leave us as soon as they can – but they don’t get a say in what we do anyway). If we do something our current folks like, we’re missing the boat.

So how do we do this? I think that designing a worship service for outsiders will require that the design team be dominated by those living on (or very close to) the borders, folks who are following Jesus, but not at the center of church life, folks who still have at least one foot in the world. These folks will have significant relationships with outsiders (unlike most of the rest of us) and have Jesus working through them to draw people in.

Posted in church growth, Evangelism, Worship | 1 Comment

Some Thoughts on Health Care “reform”

  1. We want (a) excellent, high quality health care, (b) in a timely manner, (c) available to all,  (d) at a low cost. Each group seems to major on one point while assuming the others. I don’t see how all four of those can happen at the same time.
  2. Some people have the resources to fund their own health care and some don’t.
  3. Some people have health care covered by insurance while some don’t.
  4. Some have insurance paid for by employers, some pay themselves, some through government programs.
  5. It is a good thing for people to work hard and provide for themselves and their families. Some DON’T do this, and others CAN’T do this.
  6. Compassion for others is a virtue in Christian thought. I’m surprised the Nietzscheans and Malthusians haven’t attacked this as a church/state issue, given their preferences for getting rid of the weak for the sake of the strong or the good of the whole.
  7. Many people do not like to be coerced to be compassionate.
  8. I don’t think I’m the only one who complains that his insurance costs more every year, while at the same time it pays less.
  9. Our current system SEEMS heavy on lawyers, accountants and bureaucrats.
  10. A fair percentage of Americans lack the desire or will to live healthfully.
  11. It is often a good thing to allow people to make decisions about their own lives – even if the decisions they make are stupid or unwise. At the same time we want to protect the people we love from the consequences of their bad decisions.
  12. When I take responsibility for someone else in some way, I usually gain at least some say over what they do in that area. If “we the people” (i.e., the Federal Government) take responsibility for the health care of everyone, we (the Government) will get a say over what others do and or receive when it comes to health care. We tend to be ok with that to the degree we are the ones having the control rather than the ones being controlled. We also tend to be ok with it the more we trust those who have control.
  13. Commanding (or legislating) trust is not the same thing as gaining trust. In fact, commanding trust may be antithetical to gaining trust.
Posted in Health Care | 2 Comments

Public School & Public Health Care

My brother asks (well, actually he’s passing on Rachel’s question), “Why are people so in favor of public education yet opposed to public health care?” Here are my comments.

To the degree that this is the case, I think it’s largely because “public” does not mean the same thing as “public.”

With “public” education there is still a large, though continually decreasing (and often, therefore, bemoaned) degree of local control. My trust of “public” education is partially dependent on my personal relationships with teachers, administrators, and school board people.

Most models of “public” health care seem to imply control from the top down, the top in this case, being federal bureaucrats in DC. Will I ever be in a place where I will be anything more than a client seeking patronage from experts or my social betters?

But then I might be atypical. I am not an unqualified fan of “public” education. I do what I can to support it and make it better. My wife and I have both volunteered in the schools for years. But we’re also firm believers that one size/option doesn’t fit all. For most families today it is a great sacrifice to choose anything other than public education for their children.

In general, my main negative perception of public education is that they aim too low. “Let’s get the kids to pass the TAKS test.” Sure – but that’s a MINIMUM standard, not a maximum.

In the same way, some might fear that by make health care entirely public (and I think once a significant portion of health care goes public, the cost differential will crowd out non-public – i.e., non-governmental [which is NOT the only meaning of public, though it has been pretty much reduced to that of late] – health care even more than public schooling crowds out other options), the minimum standards will be adopted. Anything more is too expensive, after all.

Posted in Current events, Education, Health Care | Leave a comment

Perfection

I’m a perfectionist. But I’m not a perfectionist in every area. I’m also not a perfectionist with everyone. I insist on perfection from myself much more often (or so I think – if you know better, let me know) than from other people. Perfectionism has it’s advantages. When we aim to be perfect, the effects we seek to bring about might be more likely – we get better results. But not always.

Sometimes I need to take up the attitude Dave Browning describes in Deliberate Simplicity: How the Church Does More by Doing Less.  Browning speaks of “excellence” instead of perfection. In his life in ministry he has seen an emphasis on excellence work to exclude people from ministry. He choose instead to push a sense of “good enough.” I like the idea of good enough. “Good enough” leaves room for grace. It allows more people to step up and try something.

The “Good enough” principles fits with the idea that “if something is worth doing, it’s worth doing poorly” (Chesterton?). More often we hear the opposite – “If something is worth doing, it’s worth doing well.”

Actually, I think both principles are true. First, if we never try something for the first time – and quite often when we first try something we’re rather poor at it – then are guaranteed to never be good at it. Second, if something is worth doing, if it is an act that truly produces good and blessing for people, then that act is not only worth doing, but it’s worth doing in a way that maximizes the goodness. Sometimes the “doing poorly” will happen in a context that allows for preparation for a different setting where excellence matters more.

As a preacher, I want my speaking to accomplish something in the lives of my hearers. I cannot be lackadaisical  about my preparation, therefore. I need to put all my effort into doing the best that I can. But I don’t come anywhere near perfection (by my own standards, at least). I’ve noticed over the years, though, that God chooses to work through me in spite of my failure to reach my own standards. I’d guess that the more imperfect I am – and the wider the audience that recognizes my imperfection – the more necessity I have for God to step in. That’s why I want to be sort of perfection-adverse. I don’t want to get to the place where I perceive myself to no longer need God. I also don’t think God wants me to get to the place where I do nothing.

So with Browning, I want to lift up the idea of “good enough.” I want to extend grace to people to try new things, to reach out in new forms of ministry. But I also want them to take the ministry seriously enough that they pour their best into, while they trust God to fill in the necessarily remaining gaps.

Posted in Discipleship, Ministry, Perfectionism | 2 Comments

Clunkers

My cars don’t quite count as clunkers. Sure, all of them have over 100k miles. Sure, the newest of them is a 2000. Sure, the car I drive doesn’t get great mileage. But none of them are listed as clunkers. But what if one was a clunker?

The ideas behind the “Cash for Clunkers” program include (a) stimulating economic activity (and the auto industry in particular) and (b) getting more fuel efficient cars on the road. Those are good ideas. But are they enough?

If my car were on the clunker list, then I could get up to $4500 for it. Then if I wanted a new car that cost $20,000 it would only cost me an additional $15,500.  The new car would get better gas mileage, so I would save some money that way, too. Let’s suppose my current car averages 19 mpg (if it were less, it would count as a clunker) and I “trade” it for a car that averages 35mpg, and gas averaged $4 a gallon, and I drove 20,000 miles a year, I would save just over $1900 dollars a year. Saving that much sounds like a good idea to me.

But if saving money is my goal, then I would save even more by not trading my car. It still has some life left in it – probably a few years. Each year I don’t buy a new car, I save more money. Sure, I spend more on gas than I would like, but since I’m not making a car payment, I can afford it.

I’m blessed with a job. I have a regular pay check. If I had to make a car payment, I could. But can all the folks taking advantage of “Cash for Clunkers” afford a new car – even if their clunker counts as a nice down payment? If the economy rebounds, and they can keep their jobs (or get jobs) and make the payments.

But I have a recollection that one of the major things that got us into this mess was our propensity to spend beyond our means. The economy needs us to spend more – for consumption to rise. But consumption will not reward us for long. The economy is not a very benevolent god for the long term.

Posted in Current events, Economics | 1 Comment